It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Thodeph
Those who call journalistic reports and children's testimonies 'hearsay' and insist upon 'facts' don't install a lot of confidence. Your chivalrish rescue of those poor, falsely accused freemasons doesn't either.
Again, it might be wiser to admit that at least a lot of indications exist that freemasons have given into paedophilic crimes, or are protecting those accused -- which amounts to the same.
Freemasons are not the only ones guilty of such acts. Catholic priests and bishops apparently can suffer from a similar disease. Which, in their case, could be explained by years of celibacy, not by the compliance to a cult's inherent amoral beliefs.
[edit on 28-2-2007 by Thodeph]
Originally posted by EdenKaia
Alright, a few things then.
First off, anything from the "freemasonwatch" website has to be taken with a grain of salt, as they have had proven hoaxes brought out publically. Apparently had something to do with complete articles, names, and events being completely fabricated. The site has since made a public apology and "were not sure how these false reports came through". Either way you look at it, this kind of kills any credibility.
Originally posted by Thodeph
Those who call journalistic reports and children's testimonies 'hearsay' and insist upon 'facts' don't install a lot of confidence.
Originally posted by Thodeph
Those who call journalistic reports and children's testimonies 'hearsay' and insist upon 'facts' don't install a lot of confidence.
Originally posted by Thodeph
Finally an admission that Freemasons were involved in the Dunbane case.
I emphasized this case as a test to Masoniclight's freethinking abilities. Unfortunately, he/she refused to review the evidence or take it seriously. People who belong to an organization without allowing criticism towards it, in my opinion, take on the characteristics of the brainwashed.
Originally posted by Thodeph
Don't feel so personally attacked.
I never said all freemasons were pederasts. I presented evidence that some were, and that others have covered up child killings to a degree that's quite disturbing. Furthermore, indications are rife that this occurs all over the world, suggesting something inherently problematic with freemasonic sexual ethics.
Apparently, instead of admitting this, cult-like denial came to the front on the legitimacy of press publications about official paedophilia scandals involving particular freemasons.
It would have sufficed for Masonic Light to admit that some freemasons have practiced paedophile actions. Instead, the usual skepticism-bluster was produced; apparently members of a cult deny any possibility that their fellowship could be prone to criminal behaviour or even moral deviance.
Originally posted by Thodeph
You're remarkable quiet about the Dunblane case also. Maybe because the judge presiding it closed the investigation for the next 100 years. The judge was revealed to be president of a Scottish freemason group.
Robert Cooper, the museum and library curator of the Grand Lodge in Edinburgh’s George Street, said: "We are going to ask for members’ permission from two lodges that Thomas Hamilton has been linked with to print the membership book on the internet to put an end to speculation over whether he was a Freemason or not. We know he wasn’t but we want everyone else to be sure as well."
It’s not just an academic exercise. The Hamilton connection has haunted the Freemasons since he shot dead 16 children, one of their teachers and himself in the school gym of Dunblane Primary in 1996. Last month, a petition was submitted by a local resident to the Scottish parliament asking for the Cullen Inquiry into the murders to be reopened to re-examine alleged Masonic links.
Cooper is more familiar than most with how the theory goes. It sprang, he says, from the clearly-recorded membership of Hamilton’s grandfather, James, a welder who joined the Garrowhill Lodge in the working class district of Baillieston in December 1957 and, after moving home, was a regular attendee at the Royal Arch Lodge in Stirling until his death in 2000.
As the grandfather was a member, then so was the grandson, so the theory progresses. As a mason, Thomas Hamilton would mix socially with other masons, many of them local police officers, the theory dictates. "Thomas Hamilton was unstable but was allowed to keep guns in his house by the police because they were all masons together," Cooper said. "None of this is true."
Membership records were scrutinised for the years in which Hamilton, who was born in 1952, could have been a member. They were from 1973, after he was 21 (you can only join at 18 if your father has been a member), to 1996 when he died. Another two Thomas Hamiltons were unearthed in Scotland but they were both the wrong ages.
"We spent months scouring the relevant documentation and no trace was found of him. Of course people will say you would say that wouldn’t you, which is why we are prepared to open the relevant parts of the register and attendance books up to scrutiny."
Since the massacre, questions have been raised about the actions of Central Scotland Police in the case, and numerous Internet conspiracy theories have arisen regarding alleged involvement by Freemasonry, George Robertson, MI6, the supporters of the Snowdrop Petition and Northern Ireland terrorist organisations.[6][7] These were, to some extent, fuelled by the 100-year restriction on publication of parts of the Cullen Inquiry into the massacre. The partial lifting of these restrictions on 3 October 2005 quelled some of the more outlandish theories. One of the victim's parents, who read the full version of all the documents before they were released, concluded there was no evidence for any conspiracy[2]. Nevertheless Dunblane conspiracy sites still persist on the web.
Lord Burton said "I was Grand Master of the Grand Lodge of Scotland at the time and I'm aware that most of the conspiracy theories around Dunblane revolve around allegations of a masonic conspiracy. (snip) ... but Hamilton was never a mason. His grandfather was.
tends to concentrate on lighter-weight news stories, such as celebrity gossip. Its fondness for sex scandals has gained it the nicknames "Sex 'n' Scandal weekly", "News of the Screws" and "Screws of the World".
Originally posted by Thodeph
As it happened, Lord Cullen did not recuse himself, even though, as I have recently discovered, he is numbered 1702 on the membership list of the ‘Speculative Society of Edinburgh’, which is an exclusive off-shoot of Freemasonry. In fact, Masons from Lodge Canongate Kilwinning No 2, founded the “Speculative Society” in Edinburgh in 1764."