It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally quoted by 25cents
and i'm saying that if you're dead set on calling someone a racist, at least know what you're talking about.
anyway, i'd like to ask - when the hell did this turn into a discussion about purchasing goods from other countries? i don't give a damn if a whole gaggle of tourists from other countries come here and buy out our wal-marts. just go back home when you're done shopping. that's how capitalism works.
ps - i agree with you canucks on the draft dodgers though.
Originally posted by ceci2006
Like it or not, Americans are taking advantage of the Canadian health system just like illegal immigrants are taking advantage of our health care system.
US Dept. of State
Tourists and temporary visitors do not qualify for this health care plan and are well advised to have their own insurance to cover any medical expenses.
Vermonters Getting Canadian Medical Care. Legally
There appears to be nothing illegal in what Dr. Bouchard and other Canadian doctors are doing. Citiizens of the US may visit Canadian doctors any time they wish. Provided an examination occurs, US citizens have little difficulty purchasing at least a month's supply of prescription drugs, and bringing them back across the border. The drugs must be declared and it is a good idea to have a copy of the prescription with you for customs examination. If you don't have an insurance plan that covers the high cost of drugs, then crossing the border and finding a Canadian doctor just makes good economic sense.
With that being said, the problem with the word "illegal" is the same way that one would not want to be called any other derogatory term.
Does anyone think that illegal immigrants are so inhuman that they don't have feelings?
If they truly wanted to not be considered "racist" in their speech, they would find another word to express their thoughts about undocumented workers.
How hard is it for those who use the term "illegals" to just say "illegal immigrants" when they refer to those who are not legal in America?
It's not about prettying up a situation. It's about expressing concern about other human beings regardless of color.
And when people use the term "illegal", they aren't talking about the situation in a fair manner any more. They are expressing their contempt and hatred for another human being.
Originally posted by ceci2006
However, I am still waiting for one Canadian to apply a pejorative term against Americans who cross the border for buying medicine outside of the country and taking advantage of their health system.
Originally posted by 25cents
speak for yourself pal. i'm willing to do anything i have to do to survive. i've done hard labor in the middle of an arizona summer to pay for gas money to get to and from college - don't tell me i'm lazy.
Originally posted by Snazuolu
i'm speaking of ALL Americans,
Originally quoted by Benevolent Heretic
Are you saying that US citizens are crossing the border illegally to take advantage of the Canadian medical system? If so, could you provide a source for this information because this is the first I've heard of it.
Officials look to recover foreigners' medical bills
Taxpayers in British Columbia are footing the medical bills for thousands of foreigners who visit the province, and government officials are looking at ways to get them to pay it back.
In a report, provincial Health Minister George Abbott said $10-million in unpaid bills have been racked up by foreigners who visit the province and obtain hospital care.
[...]
He said he's urging health authorities to look at new ways to recover lost money owed by those who have used B.C.'s hospitals or walk-in clinics while visiting.
"It's money that we would love to be able to put into other areas of health care," Ms. Germain said.
Last year, Interior Health revealed that the "bush boys," two American brothers who duped the town of Vernon by claiming they were raised in the woods, owed more than $50,000 in unpaid hospital bills.
Kyle Horn and his younger brother Roen racked up $68,000 worth of medical costs at Vernon Jubilee Hospital before they returned to their home in California two years ago.
Originally posted by ceci2006
Yes, Americans are taking advantage of the Health Care system in Canada. Here it is from the Globe and Mail.
I wanted you to know that Americans are just as responsible for taking advantage of the system of other countries just like illegal immigrants do here.
It proves that Americans are no better than the undocumented workers they describe when siphoning off services of another country.
In Canada, Americans are "illegals", "criminals" and "thieves"--especially when they don't pay medical bills and stiff the Canadian government and taxpayers with the costs.
Originally posted by Benevolent Heretic
Agreed 100%. The US citizens who do this are illegal.
Originally quoted by Benevolent Heretic
You seem to have the same state of mind that many of the illegal immigrants have - that somehow they should be immune from the law that we have to follow.
If they're not criminals, how do you define criminal? How do you define illegal?
What's wrong with calling a spade a spade? How sensitive are people that adding an additional word (immigrant) makes the term somehow politically correct and acceptable and nice?
If a person can't handle being called an 'illegal' - if it hurts their feelings too much, perhaps they should stop breaking the law. If they have to come over here to support their families and work in the fields in the heat of Arizona and California, seems to me that being called an 'illegal' is the least of their problems
NO! Where do you get that? You seem to want us to think that these people are inhuman and somehow beneath us. Sorry, we don't. That's a fantasy. That's feeding the whloe stigma that anyone who is against illegal immigration thinks they are inhuman or 'beneath us'. Well, I don't accept your judgment and I'm telling you that you are incorrect in your assumption.
You seem to have your mind made up that anyone who would use the term 'illegals' is coming from a position of moral superiority and judgment and you are incorrect. Many people use the term just like they would use "Mexican" (because someone is from Mexico) or Canuck. For many, it's simply a shorthand term that carries no animosity.
For some it does, but not for all.
Not necessarily. Everyone is not politically correct (Thank God!) If they were racist, they'd be using other terms, trust me. I live in New Mexico. I'm practically on the border. I hear what racist people call Mexicans. And it ain't "illegals". Although that term is used. That's one of the nicer terms.
It's not hard at all. I do it. But I am not (and neither are you) the 'term police'. People are free to use the language they see fit. If their language causes others to call them racist, so be it. It's just that many times, they are wrong, hence this thread.
It's not about color either. Again, bringing race into this muddies the water. That's what this thread is about. By your statement above, you are assuming racism.
Again, that's not necessarily true. And if they were... So what? What if US citizens are angry about this? What's wrong with that? I don't buy that the term is always out of that anger, and I don't buy that it's as strong as hatred, but what's wrong with being angry at someone?
Originally posted by ceci2006
Furthermore you think it's problematic by bringing race into it.
That tells me that there is something troubling about talking about illegal immigration when race is a part of it. That is why people are afraid of being called racist when talking about this.
No one can simply stay away from race when talking about illegal immigration--especially if they have an exact "picture" in their mind of what "illegals" look like.