It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by edsinger
"We're not going to set an artificial timetable," the commander-in-chief said, calling such an idea a "terrible mistake." To do so, he said, "would breathe new life into [the enemy's] cause" and undermine the new Iraqi government and the morale of U.S. troops.
Which is exactly what the "Tulipwalkers" are asking for....strange huh?
Senate Democrats reacted critically and skeptically to a report Sunday that the American commander in Iraq had privately presented a plan for significant troop reductions in the same week they came under attack by the GOP for trying to set a timetable for withdrawal.
Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., said the plan attributed to Gen. George Casey resembled the thinking of many Democrats who voted for a nonbinding resolution to begin a troop drawdown this December. That resolution was defeated on a largely party-line vote in the Senate on Thursday.
Originally posted by grimreaper797There is nothing that pisses me off more then when people use the 4th of July as a way to guilt me into feeling that I am some how unpatriotic because I don't support the current actions being taken. Why don't you stop trying to use a great day in American history to push your own little agenda.
Originally posted by grimreaper797I support the troops, especially the ones that are coming out of my own neighborhood. I don't support the Iraq war and it makes me sick to see you using the 4th of July, a day of independence and freedom, as a tool for you to push the Iraq war and make us feel less American if we don't support it.
Originally posted by edsinger
What is freedom? Is it the ability to get on a plane and go where you wish without having to worry about a bomb? How about going to a mall or market to get food without being blown up by a suicide bomber?
Originally posted by yanchek
Originally posted by edsinger
What is freedom? Is it the ability to get on a plane and go where you wish without having to worry about a bomb? How about going to a mall or market to get food without being blown up by a suicide bomber?
You are confusing freedom with security. Actual freedom and our personal perception of freedom are two different things.
Oh, and freedom does not equal liberty.
Originally posted by edsinger
Fair enough then, it makes me sick when I see Americans that do not support the troops yet claim they do. When you speak ill of them and they job they do and are required to do as per their voluntary status, you think it helps their morale? Who are you kidding? You might not spit on them when they come back, but by speaking out against their mission, you cause them issues and cheapens their lives in my humble opinion. You honestly tell me that the troops you talk to love to hear about how much those back home think their mission is crap! Do you expect me to believe this is true?
Originally posted by grimreaper797
Well lets just see then, the 4th, a day to celebrate freedom. Hmmm
What is freedom? Is it the ability to get on a plane and go where you wish without having to worry about a bomb? How about going to a mall or market to get food without being blown up by a suicide bomber? You think these are not going to happen in America? Well I hope they do not, but we are at WAR. You do not pussyfoot around and nitpick the decisions made as it only aids the enemy. So how would you deal with the stated goal of these schmucks to collapse the great satan. How do you justify it to the troops when they come back to your neighborhood? I sure as hell bet you tell them to their face that the mission was wrong do you not? You tell them that their buddies died for naught right?
Well after all its a free country so you have the right to have your opinions as do I.
And I like to celebrate the freedoms that this day represents, both those already won and those the are yet to be won...
Originally posted by edsinger
semantics...
I am free to order a airline ticket to go to Israel and visit. My security could not be guaranteed whilst there.
Our freedom as a nation was tested on 911. The enemy of freedom is terror. You do not leave your house if afraid you do not have security.....that is what this war is all about.
the ability of Americans to have the freedoms that they have come to expect, at a cost, that cost is what helps maintain the security in which you speak.
Either way, security and freedoms, they are both at risk in this new war......like it or not...
But be hopeful, we ARE winning.
Originally posted by grimreaper797
There is nothing that pisses me off more then when people use the 4th of July as a way to guilt me into feeling that I am some how unpatriotic because I don't support the current actions being taken. Why don't you stop trying to use a great day in american history to push your own little agenda.
I support the troops, especially the ones that are coming out of my own neighborhood. I don't support the Iraq war and it makes me sick to see you using the 4th of July, a day of independence and freedom, as a tool for you to push the Iraq war and make us feel less american if we don't support it.
Originally posted by grimreaper797
alright look, I support the troops. I have 3 people just in my small neighborhood that or in iraq/afganistan right now. I write them each biweekly. You don't tell me about not supporting them. Everytime I write them I make sure they know that we all love them and wish nothing more then for them to do what they must and return home safe. They don't make decisions, they follow them. I support their actions, and their actions are to follow orders. I don't agree with the orders at all, but that doesn't mean I don't support the troops for doing it.
Originally posted by grimreaper797yet every person that doesn't agree with the war you attack. Thats a damn shame.
Originally posted by grimreaper797
You can agree with the war, but don't make us people who don't look like traitors. we are free to feel about this war however we want, and in the name of freedom, just deal with that.
Originally posted by grimreaper797
Thats right. Seems to be something you look down upon...freedom.
What is freedom? Is it the ability to get on a plane and go where you wish without having to worry about a bomb? How about going to a mall or market to get food without being blown up by a suicide bomber? You think these are not going to happen in America? Well I hope they do not, but we are at WAR. You do not pussyfoot around and nitpick the decisions made as it only aids the enemy. So how would you deal with the stated goal of these schmucks to collapse the great satan. How do you justify it to the troops when they come back to your neighborhood? I sure as hell bet you tell them to their face that the mission was wrong do you not? You tell them that their buddies died for naught right?
Originally posted by grimreaper797I don't need my government to protect me. I will protect me. If I can't protect myself, well then it was my time to go.
Originally posted by grimreaper797 On Al Qaeda is more reasonable, but war on terror, can never be won.
Originally posted by grimreaper797
I do tell the troops that I don't agree with the Iraq war. I tell my neighbors about all the corruption and such in Iraq now. What I don't say is that the troops are wrong because they aren't. I will continue to tell the troops to continue following orders while we fight this war at home to get them back home. You act so patriotic, go join up. I would try to get you home as well because in the end, most of us don't want to fight. There are times where it is called for, but we still aim to end it as soon as possible.
That is just plain crap. We do need to end it, but the war will not be won that quickly. If the American public keep getting just the bad news it will end in a lost and then we will have to fight it over again. I firmly believe we make our stand now...
Originally posted by grimreaper797
You talk like your glad people are dying. Just because a war needs to be fought doesn't mean we should be vigilant to end it as soon as possible.
Originally posted by grimreaper797
I celebrate the freedoms that were won in the past, even if your war means infringing on them. Let me tell you the freedoms yet to be won will be the same exact freedoms won 230 years ago. In order to have that happen, they have to be taken away, but given the current path people like you have us headed down it shouldn't be long till thats true.
Originally posted by dawnstarhow about the freedom to speak our minds, without being labeled as unpatriotic???
Originally posted by dawnstar
securing our borders would make us much safer than the war in Iraq has made us by the way.
Originally posted by dawnstarso wouldn't getting a hold on our spending habits and showing some fiscal discipline. instead, we are making our childlren's lives very insecure with our massive debts!!
Originally posted by dawnstar
we keep going in this direction, none of our kids will have the money to pay taxi fare, let alone the money for a plane ticket!! they'll be working two full time jobs just to pay their taxes (our debt) and feed and house their families.
Originally posted by dawnstar
torture is not the american way!! regardless of what cheney and gonzalas says.
Originally posted by dawnstarneither is having a president who signs off his obedience to many of the laws he signs thinking that the rest of us should have to obey!!
Originally posted by dawnstarthere are plenty of reason to criticise this president, and when it comes to troops not getting what they need to fight the war this president sent them to fight, by God speaking up on their behalf is supporting the troops!
Originally posted by dawnstarso isn't encouraging this administration to stop messing around and start working at getting the job done so our troops can come home! at least if he had a timetable that he had to work with, maybe he'd be more apt to make sure the troops were able to achieve what is necessary instead of thinking the whole thing is about giving more $$$ to his friends?
Originally posted by grimreaper797
I can't believe this. Maybe you don't ever leave your house, but I do. Security is not garenteed till you take away every freedom you have. I have news for you, you are still not safe. You are not going to be anymore safe until you start letting the government locking you in your house.
Originally posted by edsinger
Well then you are the exception to the rule and I am sorry I thought otherwise.
Originally posted by grimreaper797
No just those who attack my sense of what the 4th is about, simple fact.
Originally posted by grimreaper797
I am sure this makes these guys feel better when getting shot at. Traitors? No not most........You are free to feel about the war like you wish. Ironic that its the troops that are protecting that exact freedom, but you disagree with this mission.
Originally posted by grimreaper797
Not all all I love freedom and I realize what this war is about, it isn't about just WMDs and Oil, its about freedom. As a side note, I sure as hell hope it spreads in the Middle East because the security sure sucks there.
Originally posted by grimreaper797
Precisely my point. You go after them guys would you.
Originally posted by grimreaper797
But it can, and it is slowly but surely.....
Originally posted by grimreaper797
I did join, at one time. I want them all to come home. But it is the big picture that eludes most sadly....
Originally posted by grimreaper797
That is just plain crap. We do need to end it, but the war will not be won that quickly. If the American public keep getting just the bad news it will end in a lost and then we will have to fight it over again. I firmly believe we make our stand now...
Originally posted by grimreaper797
Horsepucky - here we go with that patriot act crap again. We have lost some of our mobility but not our freedoms. These programs that the press likes to divulges just help the enemy. I don't give a fart whether the NSA tracks my phone calls, I have nothing to hide.......If you knew the rules the NSA had to work under, you would understand.....unless you intend to harm the US, then you have nothing to fear............ but fear itself (had to throw that in sorry)
Originally posted by edsinger
Originally posted by grimreaper797
I can't believe this. Maybe you don't ever leave your house, but I do. Security is not garenteed till you take away every freedom you have. I have news for you, you are still not safe. You are not going to be anymore safe until you start letting the government locking you in your house.
I leave, quite a bit actually and its true I have no security in some sense, but I do know that the war against my nation is not being fought in the streets of America.....yet.
From that, I do feel secure. When the Lord calls me home, I will go as it is His timing not mine.
Freedoms? What freedoms have I lost? You mean if I use a debit Card that big brother is watching? When I use my cell that he is listening? So what? What a boring way to spend the day....
Its the computers that listen and looks for "%^$". Then the humans get involved.
What freedoms have I lost? None really that I even notice.....
Originally posted by grimreaper797
There is nothing that pisses me off more then when people use the 4th of July as a way to guilt me into feeling that I am some how unpatriotic because I don't support the current actions being taken. Why don't you stop trying to use a great day in american history to push your own little agenda.
I support the troops,
Originally posted by edsinger
True Terrorism will always be there, on this day the 4th, some Brits would argue , convincingly I might add, that the pesky colonists were terrorists.
Its the war against Al qaeda in which I speak, it IS being won. Slowly but surely.