It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by kenshiro2012
Nice catch there noslenwerd.
I was noticing that the diction that both used in their postings are very similar.
Originally posted by Thain Esh Kelch
I find it interesting that one of the persons on the 12 man team died of pneumonia, which is basically impossible on another planet, since its caused by bacteria.
Anything found on that planet is 99.999% sure to not being able to be a human pathogen.
Originally posted by Centrist
I've found a few inconsistencies, as well... First, the claim is that the Eben race has no conception of "time" as we do. Then, he claims that the Eben's agreed to a time and date for a meeting. Granted that they would probably be capable of understanding our calendar, I still find that inconsistency disconcerting.
The only major problem was time. Time was different on the visitor's planet. I don't think anyone ever figured it out. The visitors had no clocks. They didn't judge or account for time as we did. The visitors found our attempts to account for time strange.
The incoming messages gave a time and date (Eben date and time system),
Originally posted by Thain Esh Kelch
I find it interesting that one of the persons on the 12 man team died of pneumonia, which is basically impossible on another planet, since its caused by bacteria.
Anything found on that planet is 99.999% sure to not being able to be a human pathogen.
Moving to the Equatorial region, our team found desert-style landscapes which contained patches of vegetation. The team found numerous pockets of water fed to the ground by Artesian Wells. This water was the freshest, containing only the unknown chemicals. It tasted good and the Ebens drank and used it. Our team still boiled it because during culture tests, unknown types of bacteria were detected.
Originally posted by SkepticOverlord
Smells like hoax.
The writing style, grammar, and choice of words do not read like that of someone who would have been an adult at the time these events occurred.
Not to mention, the laughable claim that physics would be different in another solar system really hurts the overall credibility.
Our scientists had the same questions, as posed by your audience. Our scientists questioned our team members and the information they gathered. Our scientists could not understand how the orbit of Serpo could revolve around the two suns at the distance measured.
One of the questions sent me involved Kepler's Law of Planetary Motion. Our team had that information. We had some of the best military scientists on the team. But if you consider Kepler's Law, it requires time and our team could only measure time in the conventional way. It was determined that Kepler's Laws did not apply to that solar system.
CONCLUSION: One of the things our Earth-based scientists learned was not to apply Earth's laws of physics in a universal way.
Diameter: 7,218 miles
Mass: 5.06 x 1024
Distance from Sun #1: 96.5 million miles
Sun #2: 91.4 million miles
Moons: 2
Surface gravity: 9.60m/s2
Rotation Periods: 43 hours
Orbit: 865 days
Tilt: 43 degrees
Temperature: Min: 43° / Max: 126°
Distance from Earth: 38.43 light years
Planet named by Team: SERPO
Nearest planet to SERPO: Named: OTTO
Distance:
88 million miles (colonized by Ebens with research base, but no natural inhabitants on planet)
Number of planets in Eben Solar System: Six
Nearest inhabited planet to SERPO:
Named: SILUS (SILUS is made up of creatures of various types, but no intelligent life forms. Ebens use the planet to mine minerals.)
Distance: 434 million miles
After reading Dr. Sagan's remarks on the Serpo project, which is about 60 jam-packed pages of calculations, I found one paragraph which states that in order to use Kepler's law – in the case of Planet Serpo – one had to vary the exact gravitational pull placed on Serpo by the two suns. Serpo did not have large planets, like Jupiter and Saturn to affect the gravitational pull as the Earth does. Serpo's gravitational pull was different than anything Dr. Sagan had ever seen before.
There are numerous figures and calculations to support this. I will forward them at a later date. Have your list stay tuned.
In response to the intensive ongoing debate recorded in the Comments section of this site, I would like to endorse this clarification from a prominent physicist on the list:
The senior theory (essentially proven) is Newton's inverse square law for gravity. For a simple system, Kepler's Laws are a fallout of what a planetary solution looks like (for the simple case of a single planet circling a massive sun). For a complex situation (like a planet interacting with two suns, several planets, or whatever) you have to go back to Newton's law and solve a many-body problem which takes a computer. In this case Kepler's Laws are only an approximation, since they hold only for the simplest case.
Kepler's laws of planetary motion may be derived from these laws[Newton's law of universal gravitation and Newton's laws of motion], when it is assumed that the orbiting body is subject only to the gravitational force of the central attractor.
Originally posted by Valhall
He states
The visitors had no clocks. They didn't judge or account for time as we did. The visitors found our attempts to account for time strange.
and then in regards to the sixth message you cite he states
The incoming messages gave a time and date (Eben date and time system),
Now...where's the inconsistency?
Originally posted by Valhall
Originally posted by Thain Esh Kelch
I find it interesting that one of the persons on the 12 man team died of pneumonia, which is basically impossible on another planet, since its caused by bacteria.
Anything found on that planet is 99.999% sure to not being able to be a human pathogen.
Why is it impossible?
he states
Moving to the Equatorial region, our team found desert-style landscapes which contained patches of vegetation. The team found numerous pockets of water fed to the ground by Artesian Wells. This water was the freshest, containing only the unknown chemicals. It tasted good and the Ebens drank and used it. Our team still boiled it because during culture tests, unknown types of bacteria were detected.
Originally posted by kenshiro2012
Actually, it depends on what bacteria caused the pneumonia.
Example Staphylococcus aureus
Can be transfered to the human host from tainted food.
vm.cfsan.fda.gov...
Also there are many viruses (another cause of pnemonia) as well as bacteria that can lie in a dormant stage for years and in some cases centuries. One of the other "team members" could have acted like a typhoon mary and the exchangee that died could have caught it from the other.
Originally posted by Centrist
I think you summed up the inconsistency quite well -- the earlier message states that the Ebens do not account for time like we do. The later message states that the Ebens have a date and time system of their own. Either they use times and dates or they don't. If they had a time and date system of their own, why would they find "our attempts to account for time strange" if they account for time using a time/date system?
Perhaps you could help me out by reconciling the two statements?
[edit on 1-12-2005 by Centrist]
our time instruments did not work on Serpo.
Now, considering this, you can understand the difficult job our team members had making calculations without time. They had to come up with an alternate method to measure speeds, orbits, etc.
Challenge: Try solving a problem in physics without being able to measure time on Earth!
Originally posted by Thain Esh Kelch
Unless they have the same ancestor, which I really dont expect, these cells arent bacteria. They can be anything else, but the chance that they produce anything that could harm our body, or do so before being destroyed by our own stomach-flora, is quite small.
The reason they call it bacteria, is probably because they could see small cells, but they didnt have any high-tech equipment like an electron-microscope.
Notice that they didnt have any biologist with them, which could explain why they just call them bacteria like any other person.
Of notice btw, I only meant microbial pathogens, not 'naturally' occuring chemicals.
Originally posted by kenshiro2012
Actually, it depends on what bacteria caused the pneumonia.
Example Staphylococcus aureus
Can be transfered to the human host from tainted food.
vm.cfsan.fda.gov...
Also there are many viruses (another cause of pnemonia) as well as bacteria that can lie in a dormant stage for years and in some cases centuries. One of the other "team members" could have acted like a typhoon mary and the exchangee that died could have caught it from the other.
Yes, some bacteria can lie dormant for literally an eternity. Virus can not in most cases, but thats a whole other story.
Anyway, 2 things counts against the pneumonia story:
1. To get an bacterial infection, you need lots of cells in your body, depending on microbial species. You dont have an 'infectious bombs' lying around in equipment, especially not when it has probably been sterilised before departure.
2. This team is the best of the best, so they have also been in physical perfect shape, and you dont just die of pneumonia. Young children and older person do, but thats because their immuno system isnt up to the task. They might have been weakened by the environment as the text also notices, but I still dont believe that this could have been the cause.
I think the discrepancy exists in your mind and not my mind, so I probably can't.