It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Oblivions void
drogo do you really think that the baath/saddam insurgents or the religous/taliban like insurgents are really going to offer a more freedom and a better life than the american puppet government would? like I said before we know what went on in iraq when saddam was in power (yo gotta be a complete BLANKING Idiot to think that was an ideal situation) and we know how the taliban ran afghanistan. Even been an american puppet they would have greater freedom than the vast majority of the middle east. The only real damage being cause in iraq now is a direct result of the insurgency.
Let’s get pass the right and wrong argument, because anybody with half a brain would know that anybody who is willing to die for something thinks he is right.
Bypass for a second if you can your obvious bias against America
ask yourself under whom would Iraqis have a better future (not Ideal or Perfect mind you), or let’s put it this way who you really want to live under, a psychopath like saddam and his sons, a Taliban type government or a puppet US government who would just be giving them an extra sweet deal on Oil and fork over some space for some military bases to intimidate their neighbors mostly who don’t particular like Iraq to begin with and would have not qualms about attacking it. So come on get off your anti-American horse for a second and honestly think, do you think that a puppet US government is worse than a Taliban-style or a psychotic dictatorship with a systematic torture and death squads.
I mean look at germany and japan, they should lived and matured in a complete hell hole thanks to American occupation, 2 of the richest and most industrialized nations in the world I would frankly prefer to live in either of those countries the way things are going here.
Like I said the whole selective name calling (terrorist/name calling) irks me a lot, I for one don’t need the added FALSE justifications of name calling to agree or disagree, it’s quite shallow if you simply go by whatever labels the powers that be choose to imposed on something. So like I asked before, do you honestly believe that saddam or the religious zealots are going to honestly offer the Iraqi people a better way of life than what the US would bring, I mean saddam has killed hundreds of thousand more Iraqi than the Americans, the insurgency is on the way to surpassing the death toll from all American operations in Iraq and their collateral damage the way they are going.
Originally posted by phoenixhasrisin
Lest we forget....SADDAM WAS PUT INTO POWER BY THE AMERICANS.
This puppet government will be no diffrerent from the previous one, and the insurgents know this.
America places people in power all around the world with the hopes, that they will remain loyal to our "national interest". As shown time and time again, it just does not work.
All the arguments I have heard have basically amounted to "If they want us out then why are they fighting us". They are fighting us because our soldiers are on their soil, acting with impunity.
ANY SELF RESPECTING AMERICAN WOULD DO THE EXACT SAME THING IF ANY SOLDIERS OF ANY NATION WERE ON OUR SOIL!
As for the insurgency targetting "civillians". That has been a popular tactic amongst freedom fighters for as long as time itself.
All I know is, if foreign fighters were in my town, and people in my town were helping them to destroy fellow countrymen, and rat on their neighbors .......Then they would be considered fair game......and rightfully so.
Originally posted by ThatsJustWeird
Please, I'm begging you. Just read/know a little bit of history before posting. Just the tiniest bit would have helped you in this case. America had nothing to do with Saddam coming into power. People like you are so quick to blame America for stuff they forget the facts.
We supported Saddam when he fought against Iran. He was already in power then. If you knew any history you would have known that.
How was Saddam's reign a puppet one? lol
Read a book dude.
And how do you know this government will turn out to be a dictatorship? Like all new democracies, this one will go through growing pains, but how do you know it'll fail?
Better question: Why do you want it to fail?
Examples would be?
The Americans among us who are civilized would fight against the invaders themselves and the people helping them, not innocent bystanders minding their own business. You and drago are idiots if you think the people these insurgents are blowing up should be considered collaborators if they're not helping the insurgency. 98% (putting it low) of these people are doing the same things they were doing before we arrived. Why weren't they considered enemies of the state then?
Give examples.
Give examples where it has worked? It has never in history worked before so why do you feel it would work now?
Ture, too bad for you we aren't doing that. We're helping rebuild the country and establish order.
No one would even know who they were if they didn't blow themselves up. They aren't in any danger. If you lined up 100 Iraqis, two were insurgents can you pick out which ones were the insurgents? No.
It's all a twisted mindset.
Do you honestly believe that these insurgents believe that if they kill enough people we will leave? Tell me, do you honestly believe they believe that?
Do you honestly believe they don't know that by doing what they're doing they're making things worse and the country less free?
Do you honestly believe that they don't know if they continue and increase MORE foriegn troops would come instead of less?
Do you believe the insurgents really that stupid?
Maybe they are.
Or many they just don't care.
Either way these morons (and yes, any one who goes around randomly killing innocent people are less than human) aren't fighting for anyone's freedom.
Originally posted by Oblivions void
As was stated above saddam was already in power when the US backed him, the US has rarely gone in and completely taken down a government to build it back up.
Originally posted by Muaddib
Saddam was put as vice-president by the then president of Iraq al-bakr...latter on Saddam decided it was time for him to be the president and he became president of Iraq.
Anyways, what else is new...another communist wannabe trying to blame the US for everything that happens i the world.
Originally posted by lukethedrifter
He said the US is a state of Israel!!!
Originally posted by phoenixhasrisin
What's wrong can't dispute the facts so you resort to name calling? I never said I was communist either. You should not assume.
And yes the USA has had their hands dirty for a while now. They do not create all problems but they do create more than their fair share.
Originally posted by lukethedrifter
French, Russian, American, .........the illegal state of israel.
Up above in that rambling post. Have you considered comitting yourself to an asylum?
[edit on 16-5-2005 by lukethedrifter]
Originally posted by Muaddib
Oh, so it wasn't you who said in another thread that you have communist ideas and you were backing communism proclaiming that communist regimes have not been true to communism?.....
I just find it hilarious how people like yourself just keep attacking the US for whatever agenda you have in mind...
Anyways, where are you from?