It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Protesters are demanding the government reach a deal to bring the hostages back from Gaza, for new elections and the resignation of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The demonstration took place as a delegation of the Palestinian militant group Hamas was in Cairo for cease-fire talks with Israel.
originally posted by: gortex
Israel's implementation of their "Hannibal Directive" pretty much sealed many of their fates , just like those poor Israelis killed by the IDF on Oct 7th.
.
originally posted by: gortex
there is evidence provided by witnesses the IDF did kill Israelis both from the air and on the ground on Oct 7th.
originally posted by: FlyersFan
originally posted by: gortex
Israel's implementation of their "Hannibal Directive" pretty much sealed many of their fates , just like those poor Israelis killed by the IDF on Oct 7th.
.
No, Israel did not kill any Israelis on Oct 7. There is ZERO proof of that and all the propaganda that has been posted here claiming that has been debunked. And there is ZERO evidence that any 'Hannibal Directive' was implemented either. That old Hannibal Directive supposedly only applied to soldiers not letting other soldiers be taken captive by terrorists and it supposedly was 'cancelled' in 2016.
As to the protests to 'bring back the hostages'. Israel and the USA say that most of them are probably dead. The ones that came back have said that they were beaten, and starved, and tortured, and raped, and psychologically abused, and not given medication that was needed etc etc etc ... all at the hands of Jew hating Muslim terrorists who were just itching to kill them just like they mass murdered 1200 people on Oct 7. So of course most, if not all, of the remaining hostages are dead. It's to be expected with Hamas and the 'palestinians'. That's their mentality.
originally posted by: DAVID64
a reply to: gortex
I have serious doubts that those hostages are still alive.
Hamas tried to use them to stop Israel from a counter attack, but Israel has been bombing the hell out of them anyway. If the hostages didn't work as a deterrent, they had no value so.....
originally posted by: DAVID64
a reply to: gortex
I have serious doubts that those hostages are still alive.
Hamas tried to use them to stop Israel from a counter attack, but Israel has been bombing the hell out of them anyway. If the hostages didn't work as a deterrent, they had no value so.....
originally posted by: gortex
a reply to: DAVID64
There are probably a few still alive but Israel's implementation of their "Hannibal Directive" pretty much sealed many of their fates , just like those poor Israelis killed by the IDF on Oct 7th.
When the lives of your own citizens came second to political motivation you know there's a problem.
originally posted by: gortex
a reply to: FlyersFan
No, Israel did not kill any Israelis on Oct 7.
That is not true it's merely a belief held by and puppeted by you , there is evidence provided by witnesses the IDF did kill Israelis both from the air and on the ground on Oct 7th.
You're saying it's Israel's fault that the tortured, gang-raped, mentally and physically abused hostages taken to Gaza by Hamas are dead?
originally posted by: gortex
a reply to: CarlLaFong
You're saying it's Israel's fault that the tortured, gang-raped, mentally and physically abused hostages taken to Gaza by Hamas are dead?
those I apportion blame for that to are those who implemented the "Hannibal Directive" which basically says a dead hostage is better than a live hostage
Do you apportion any blame at all to Hamas
who deliberately sets up military headquarters and weapons dumps under/in hospitals, schools and other civilian areas
where hostages have been taken?
originally posted by: CarlLaFong
Hamas is deliberately and cowardly using Israeli/international hostages and Palestinian civilians as human shields.
Hamas are terrorists.
Hamas is 100% responsible for any of their deaths.
Placing blame for their deaths on anyone else but Hamas...makes one a Hamas/terrorist sympathizer.
Placing blame for their deaths on anyone else but Hamas...makes one a Hamas/terrorist sympathizer.
originally posted by: Dalamax
originally posted by: CarlLaFong
Hamas is deliberately and cowardly using Israeli/international hostages and Palestinian civilians as human shields.
Hamas are terrorists.
Hamas is 100% responsible for any of their deaths.
Placing blame for their deaths on anyone else but Hamas...makes one a Hamas/terrorist sympathizer.
Takes two to tango. It is possible to apportion blame in appropriate proportions without necessarily supporting or sympathising with either party.
Reality is rarely black and white.