It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Governor Greg Abbott today ceremonially signed the Save Women’s Sports Act passed during the 88th Regular Legislative Session at the Texas Women’s Hall of Fame in Denton. The Governor was joined by former NCAA athletes and spokeswomen for Independent Women's Voice Riley Gaines and Paula Scanlan and a dozen other female athletes to celebrate this momentous law to protect the integrity of fair competition and women's sports in Texas.
"We gather today at the Texas Women's Hall of Fame, which was founded in 1984 by the Texas Governor's Commission for Women to recognize women who have attained extraordinary achievements and ensure those achievements and contributions are written into our state's legacy," said Governor Abbott. “Women have thrived under college sports. They have mastered discipline, spurred drive, and cast visions inspired by a work ethic to achieve greatness. They have learned to triumph with grace and how to gracefully accept failure. They have learned how to hone skills and then translate them into successful careers and families. The legacy of women’s sports will now be safeguarded for generations to come.”
“I am thankful to Governor Greg Abbott for supporting women and girls at all levels of competitive sport—including collegiate athletes,” said Gaines. “By signing the Save Women’s Sports Act, Governor Abbott has sent a powerful message to Texans and to all Americans that we must protect the female category in sports if women and girls are to have equal athletic opportunities required by law.”
Witnesses say trans activists and allies spat and shouted at attendees at a North Texas ceremonial signing of a new state law that prohibits biological males from competing against women in collegiate athletics.
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott was joined by former NCAA athletes and a number of pro-women activists Monday for the signing of the Save Women’s Sports Act at the Texas Women’s Hall of Fame in Denton, about 20 miles northwest of Dallas.
Under Senate Bill 15, a biological male is prohibited from competing in a college-level athletic competition designated for a biological female athlete to maintain competitive fairness. The bill also creates a mechanism for people to seek injunctive relief against any Texas public college or university or intercollegiate athletic team if it violates the provisions of the bill.
At the University of Pennsylvania, Scanlan was a teammate of trans swimmer Lia Thomas, who joined the women’s team in 2021 after previously swimming on the men’s team.
Any discussion of maintaining the sanctity of women’s spaces is labeled as transphobic, bigoted and hateful,” Scanlan said. “What’s bigoted and hateful is discrimination against women and girls happening across the country.
“The dangerous effect is to erase women and girls, destroy us and our equal opportunities to compete and win.”
"Any amount of common sense you can easily comprehend the fact men on average, this is fact, are taller, stronger, more powerful, can jump higher than women,' said Gaines. "It’s biological reality, but unfortunately we live in such a time where it’s controversial to say men and women are different."
Each person normally has one pair of sex chromosomes in each cell. The Y chromosome is present in males, who have one X and one Y chromosome, while females have two X chromosomes.
originally posted by: FlyersFan2
THIS decides who will compete in Texas. Not emotions.
Chromosomes
Each person normally has one pair of sex chromosomes in each cell. The Y chromosome is present in males, who have one X and one Y chromosome, while females have two X chromosomes.
originally posted by: DAVID64
a reply to: FlyersFan2
They want to "follow the Science" until it's not on their side. Teachers have been fired for saying that, according to Biology, there are only 2 genders.
“This discriminatory law does nothing to help women’s sports and could put all college sports in Texas at risk for athletes, fans, and businesses by conflicting with NCAA Title IX rules,” Ash Hall, Policy & Advocacy Strategist at the ACLU of Texas, stated when Abbott signed the bill in June.
Like other recently-passed anti-LGBTQ+ legislation, the law empowers Texas residents to bring civil actions against targets of the bill, creating a citizen-enforcement mechanism that can be exploited by far-right organizations pursuing discriminatory outcomes in the state.
In March, the Austin American-Statesman reported there were no openly transgender athletes competing at any of the state’s four-year universities involved in NCAA-sanctioned sports.
Thirteen schools, including the University of Texas and Texas State University, said they weren’t aware of ever having had a transgender athlete compete in their programs.
“This is an answer to a problem that doesn’t exist,” said Andrea Segovia, senior field and policy adviser for the Transgender Education Network of Texas, in June. “What are the priorities of the state is always my question.”
LINK
originally posted by: Mantiss2021
a reply to: FlyersFan2
Don't Male-to-Female (MF) transsexuals take (male) testosterone-blocking hormones, and supplant then with (female) hormones (estrogen)?
If the concern was, truly, that males, claiming to be females might have an unfair advantage due to their testosterone-based strength, and thus "threaten" women's sports,
Would not the presence of testosterone-blockers in the "pretenders'" blood eliminate that concern? Athletes, at all levels are tested for "performance enhancing substances", the presence of unusually high levels of testosterone in a female athlete (East German women's gymnastics team..) should be enough to disqualify a participant.
FWIW, isn't extremely doubtful that an "intact and unaltered" Male would willing submit to what amounts to Castration, either via surgery or pharmaceuticals, just to gain a performance advantage in a sport?
And if someone were to go to such extreme lengths, that might be the appropriate time to consider regulatory restrictions for that particular individual.
Seems like this law is intended only to further ostracize an already marginalized community.
Seems like this law is intended only to further ostracize an already marginalized community.
'I can still hit a golf ball 280 yards after seven YEARS of hormone therapy - there's a lot of testosterone left over!' Caitlyn Jenner doubles down on criticism of Lia Thomas being allowed to swim as a woman and calls for stricter NCAA rules
"Any amount of common sense you can easily comprehend the fact men on average, this is fact, are taller, stronger, more powerful, can jump higher than women,' said Gaines. "It’s biological reality, but unfortunately we live in such a time where it’s controversial to say men and women are different."
originally posted by: AdifferentOpinion
Oh look! Another ATS pile-on thread bashing trans people, what a surprise!
This has little to do with women’s sports that most people don’t give two sh!ts about anyway and this signing ceremony nothing but grandstanding for a bill that was signed in JUNE.
“This discriminatory law does nothing to help women’s sports and could put all college sports in Texas at risk for athletes, fans, and businesses by conflicting with NCAA Title IX rules,” Ash Hall, Policy & Advocacy Strategist at the ACLU of Texas, stated when Abbott signed the bill in June.
Like other recently-passed anti-LGBTQ+ legislation, the law empowers Texas residents to bring civil actions against targets of the bill, creating a citizen-enforcement mechanism that can be exploited by far-right organizations pursuing discriminatory outcomes in the state.
In March, the Austin American-Statesman reported there were no openly transgender athletes competing at any of the state’s four-year universities involved in NCAA-sanctioned sports.
Thirteen schools, including the University of Texas and Texas State University, said they weren’t aware of ever having had a transgender athlete compete in their programs.
“This is an answer to a problem that doesn’t exist,” said Andrea Segovia, senior field and policy adviser for the Transgender Education Network of Texas, in June. “What are the priorities of the state is always my question.”
LINK
Seems like all of Texas’ problems are now solved? Kudos for keeping up the good work ATS and letting your true colors shine through.
originally posted by: AdifferentOpinion
Oh look! Another ATS pile-on thread bashing trans people, what a surprise!
This has little to do with women’s sports
that most people don’t give two sh!ts about anyway and this signing ceremony nothing but grandstanding for a bill that was signed in JUNE.
Seems like all of Texas’ problems are now solved?
Kudos for keeping up the good work ATS and letting your true colors shine through.
originally posted by: Mantiss2021
Seems like this law is intended only to further ostracize an already marginalized community.
originally posted by: FlyersFan2
a reply to: Mantiss2021
Daily Mail
'I can still hit a golf ball 280 yards after seven YEARS of hormone therapy - there's a lot of testosterone left over!' Caitlyn Jenner doubles down on criticism of Lia Thomas being allowed to swim as a woman and calls for stricter NCAA rules
All that adding and deleting of hormones and testosterone does NOT erase the advantage men have over actual real women in sports. This bill protects women from men taking over their sports. It's a common sense bill.
And from the opening post ... there is a lot more to the advantage men have over women in sports ...
Fox News 4 'Save Womens Sports Act'
"Any amount of common sense you can easily comprehend the fact men on average, this is fact, are taller, stronger, more powerful, can jump higher than women,' said Gaines. "It’s biological reality, but unfortunately we live in such a time where it’s controversial to say men and women are different."
originally posted by: Mantiss2021
FWIW, isn't extremely doubtful that an "intact and unaltered" Male would willing submit to what amounts to Castration, either via surgery or pharmaceuticals, just to gain a performance advantage in a sport?
Transgender swimmer Lia Thomas is so well-endowed that female swimmer Riley Gaines had “refrain from looking” at Thomas in the locker room they shared during a meet.
In a new podcast with Bill Maher dropping Sunday, Gaines, an advocate for women’s sports, repeatedly declined to estimate Thomas’ size but explained it is in proportion to the frame of a “6-foot-4 male.”
Gaines tied against Thomas in the 2022 NCAA Championships and since has become an outspoken activist against biological men in women’s sports – saying it was unfair and that changing alongside Thomas in the locker room was weird and awkward.
Some swimmers undressed in the janitor’s closet to avoid Thomas.
Thomas is 6-foot-3, putting her height in the 98th percentile for men and literally off the chart for women. Although, in accordance with NCAA rules, Thomas has been on hormone replacement therapy for over a year (the 22-year-old told Sports Illustrated she began in 2019), the body developed by male puberty remains. Her hips are narrow, not remotely wide enough to birth a child, and her lean legs and torso connected without a hint of a curve. Her jacket is hung like a cape over strapping, broad shoulders, concealing a chest flat as a board.
The two women next to Thomas swam without the advantage of large hands and a disproportionately long torso, having less height to overpower the resistance created by the greater circumference of biologically female hips. The women who excel in swimming, like other aerobic sports such as running, largely tend to have slimmer and less curvy bodies than average, but especially next to Thomas, the difference between even elite cisgendered female athletes and a trans one cannot be ignored. Weyant's thighs are undeniably curved, and Sullivan's shoulders and chest are rounder.
Scientifically speaking, these differences also translate to significant differences in body fat. Whereas elite male athletes can safely maintain body fat percentages down in the single digits, women require, at minimum, 11% body fat in order to maintain regular periods, although many require much more fat to do so.
So ignore the political and biological aspects of the debate, and just consider the raw physics. Wider hips and other curves create greater frontal resistance while swimming than an overall narrower body, and greater body fat percentages render those bodies more buoyant. All of this explains how both Weyant and Sullivan are literal Olympians, whereas Thomas was ranked in the mid-500s among men in the 500-yard freestyle.
originally posted by: Mantiss2021
originally posted by: FlyersFan2
a reply to: Mantiss2021
Daily Mail
'I can still hit a golf ball 280 yards after seven YEARS of hormone therapy - there's a lot of testosterone left over!' Caitlyn Jenner doubles down on criticism of Lia Thomas being allowed to swim as a woman and calls for stricter NCAA rules
All that adding and deleting of hormones and testosterone does NOT erase the advantage men have over actual real women in sports. This bill protects women from men taking over their sports. It's a common sense bill.
And from the opening post ... there is a lot more to the advantage men have over women in sports ...
Fox News 4 'Save Womens Sports Act'
"Any amount of common sense you can easily comprehend the fact men on average, this is fact, are taller, stronger, more powerful, can jump higher than women,' said Gaines. "It’s biological reality, but unfortunately we live in such a time where it’s controversial to say men and women are different."
The average LPGA drive distance is 250 yards, so Jenner isn't that much better than average. The average PGA drive is 300 yards.
Furthermore, if as Jenner states "...there's a lot of testosterone left over...", that would be an indication that the hormone therapy protocol isn't being followed correctly. A drug test would therefore disqualify Her participation, would it not?
If they are going to test for drugs and now, chromosomes, why not include testosterone/estrogen levels as well?