a reply to:
TheMirrorSelf
I have a list of ratings for shows that I've seen or are currently watching, which includes shows that are my favorite as well as shows that I really
don't like (usually the more modern shows, some of which are either produced by Netflix or are on Netflix). Personally, I don't think anything truly
good has ever come out of a Netflix production. For me Netflix has ruined quality entertainment because all the internet streaming companies are
copying their model of cheap boring assembly line shows (quantity over quality). But the highest rated Netflix production in that list is The Witcher,
which I rated at 4.9. I only watched it because Game of Thrones (7.3) ended (I would rate GoT higher if it weren't for the last season). Since I don't
have a Netflix subscription, it's a little hard to see which of the shows in my list are on Netflix, that would be easier for you. My favorite genres
are Sci-Fi, Fantasy, History and War, my least favorite are those that depict contemporary realism (detective shows and such). Here's my list as of
now (those still running are marked with a *):
Stargate SG-1 (9)
Stargate Atlantis (8.8)
Babylon 5 (8.5)
Star Trek DS9 (8)
Blackadder (7.9)
Game of Thrones (7.3)
Band of Brothers (7.2)
Hatfields & McCoys (7.1)
Hornblower (7)
Stargate Universe (6.4) (referred to as SGU in my commentary below)
ST TNG (6.3) (Star Trek: The Next Generation)
The Expanse (6.2)* (on Amazon now)
Picard (6.1)*
Space: Above and Beyond (6)
The Mandalorian (6)* (Disney+)
Loki (6)* (Disney+)
Firefly (5.9)
ST Voyager and Enterprise (5.8)
Farscape (5.6)
The old BSG (5.5) (BSG = Battlestar Galactica)
Lost (5)
The Witcher (4.9)*
The Dark Crystal (4.8)
What If...? (4.7)*
Deadwood (4.5)
ST Discovery (4)*
Heroes (3.6)
The Last Kingdom (3.5)*
Black Sails (3.4)
The Orville (3.3)*
WandaVision (3.2)
Ash vs Evil Dead (3.1)
Dark Matter (3)
Lost in Space (2.9)*
Rome (2.8)
The Boys (2.7)*
Krypton (2.3)
His Dark Materials (2.2)*
Stranger Things (2.1)*
Andromeda (2)
Doctor Who (1.9)*
Falling Skies (1.7)
Merlin (1.6)
TWD (1.5)* (The Walking Dead)
See (1.4)*
FTWD (1.3)* (Fear TWD)
The new BSG (1) (mostly because of how they wasted their high budget, it's not technically this bad; this represents my frustration with modern shows
compared to older shows)
Shows that are hard to rate because I stopped watching:
Dr. Who (not my type of show, but I stuck with it for quite a few seasons when there were no space Sci-Fi shows running after SGU was cancelled in
2011 and before the Expanse started in 2015; this was also the time when I watched Falling Skies and Merlin out of sheer desperation.)
The Last Ship (lost interest at the start of season 3, was never really that into it anyway)
Prison Break (first season was interesting, after the prison break, show could have ended for me. I skimmed through season 2, season 3 had another
prison break which was not as interesting as season 1 anymore, and I think I stopped watching somewhere in season 4)
The Librarians (unisex version of Charmed I guess, by skimming through it, I almost made it till the end)
Hell on Wheels (I got stuck somewhere in season 2 or 3, got too bored with it; years later I tried Deadwood, which I enjoyed a lot more)
Sharpe (when I was looking into Hornblower-type shows, I may have seen all episodes, but being less interesting than Hornblower, and a long time since
I've seen it, I find it hard to rate in comparison with the others; somewhere in between Lost and Deadwood? 5 - 4.5; the lead actor, i.e. Sharpe =
Boromir from LOTR)
Turn
Red Dwarf (which I never actually stopped watching because I never started, but what episodes I did see on the BBC were quite funny)
Since I wrote the above, I've watched another season of Dr. Who up to S8E5, and decided to rate it anyway (see list, 1.9; still not my type of show
with all the standalone episodes, and too much promotion of wokeness).
I was thinking about watching Vikings next, but I don't really want to because it looks like a typical modern show produced by an internet streaming
company. So perhaps I should skip ahead to one of the superhero shows from Marvel or DC, it looks like they put the most money into The Falcon and the
Winter Soldier, but neither superhero interests me (remember what I said about contemporary realism?). Here's my list of series still to watch (by the
way, I'm List-Man, that's my superhero power):
See (already started)
Dr. Who (see commentary before)
Krypton (2018) (seen and ended; so I should probably take this out)
What If...? (2021) (just saw the most recently aired episode, bringing me to...)
Vikings
World Without End (2012)
Marco Polo
The Falcon and the Winter Soldier
Titans
Legends of Tomorrow (Spun-off from Arrow and The Flash; crossovers with Supergirl, Freedom Fighters: The Ray, Batwoman, Vixen; also DC: Doom Patrol,
Black Lightning, Stargirl, Gotham, Smallville, Constantine)
The Defenders (follows Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage and Iron Fist; also Netflix: The Punisher)
Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. (also ABC: Agent Carter, Inhumans; other Marvel series: Runaways, Cloak & Dagger, Helstrom)
Guardians of the Galaxy (and other Marvel cartoons)
Star Wars: The Clone Wars
Star Wars: Rebels
Westworld
Yellowstone
Tremors
edit on 18-9-2021 by whereislogic because: (no reason given)