It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: thesaneone
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: burdman30ott6
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
Do you stand in your home? If no, you need to look in a mirror and ask why you are such a blatant liar with your feelings. That is unless you never thought about it before, which I would surmise comprises 90% of you or more.
There are a lot of things done in a stadium that nobody does at home, and vise versa. This OP is a horribly poor argument. How many people bow their heads and pray when they see it on TV versus bowing their heads and praying at the dinner table in their home? How many people shoot off fireworks in their living room while watching the 4th of July programming from the major cities? How many people throw slime at their television when watching a live Nickelodian program?
So again the answer is no. Thanks. I'm using this thread and the responses to make another one. I appreciate your input.
So you admit to baiting the members?
Not at all. I asked a simple question. Can you answer it?
originally posted by: c2oden
originally posted by: 3NL1GHT3N3D1
a reply to: c2oden
I guess I just choose to not let the state dictate what is right or wrong for me.
How do you feel about North Koreans honoring dear leader out of tradition and being disowned or punished for not toeing the line? Do you think it's fair that they are punished for not bowing down to Kim?
Take a look in the mirror, you're guilty of the same thing except with a flag.
You are missing the point entirely.
It has nothing to do with the "state".
It is about showing respect for something that deserves respect.
It is about respecting what the flag stands for, and honoring those who have fought for which it stands.
It has nothing to do with politics or agendas.
Show some respect.
originally posted by: thesaneone
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: thesaneone
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: burdman30ott6
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
Do you stand in your home? If no, you need to look in a mirror and ask why you are such a blatant liar with your feelings. That is unless you never thought about it before, which I would surmise comprises 90% of you or more.
There are a lot of things done in a stadium that nobody does at home, and vise versa. This OP is a horribly poor argument. How many people bow their heads and pray when they see it on TV versus bowing their heads and praying at the dinner table in their home? How many people shoot off fireworks in their living room while watching the 4th of July programming from the major cities? How many people throw slime at their television when watching a live Nickelodian program?
So again the answer is no. Thanks. I'm using this thread and the responses to make another one. I appreciate your input.
So you admit to baiting the members?
Not at all. I asked a simple question. Can you answer it?
Would you believe me?
originally posted by: thesaneone
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: thesaneone
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: burdman30ott6
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
Do you stand in your home? If no, you need to look in a mirror and ask why you are such a blatant liar with your feelings. That is unless you never thought about it before, which I would surmise comprises 90% of you or more.
There are a lot of things done in a stadium that nobody does at home, and vise versa. This OP is a horribly poor argument. How many people bow their heads and pray when they see it on TV versus bowing their heads and praying at the dinner table in their home? How many people shoot off fireworks in their living room while watching the 4th of July programming from the major cities? How many people throw slime at their television when watching a live Nickelodian program?
So again the answer is no. Thanks. I'm using this thread and the responses to make another one. I appreciate your input.
So you admit to baiting the members?
Not at all. I asked a simple question. Can you answer it?
Would you believe me?
originally posted by: Deaf Alien
originally posted by: thesaneone
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: thesaneone
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: burdman30ott6
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
Do you stand in your home? If no, you need to look in a mirror and ask why you are such a blatant liar with your feelings. That is unless you never thought about it before, which I would surmise comprises 90% of you or more.
There are a lot of things done in a stadium that nobody does at home, and vise versa. This OP is a horribly poor argument. How many people bow their heads and pray when they see it on TV versus bowing their heads and praying at the dinner table in their home? How many people shoot off fireworks in their living room while watching the 4th of July programming from the major cities? How many people throw slime at their television when watching a live Nickelodian program?
So again the answer is no. Thanks. I'm using this thread and the responses to make another one. I appreciate your input.
So you admit to baiting the members?
Not at all. I asked a simple question. Can you answer it?
Would you believe me?
Would anyone believe the polls?
originally posted by: Nyiah
originally posted by: LesMisanthrope
originally posted by: Nyiah
originally posted by: LesMisanthrope
originally posted by: Nyiah
originally posted by: LesMisanthrope
originally posted by: Nyiah
originally posted by: LesMisanthrope
a reply to: Nyiah
Because the are in public with a large group of their fellow citizens.
But a packed sports bar is not a large group of their fellow citizens and thus no ritual warranted.
You folks make zero sense, it;s obvious flag & anthem etiquette necessity is HIGHLY subjective to you. You just won't admit it.
But it is etiquette. That’s the point, no matter what anyone thinks of the flag.
Would you take your shoes off at the Taj Mahal, even though you weren’t Muslim nor Indian?
It is selectively applied etiquette. If it's not necessary for a packed bar to display the etiquette, then you must concede it's not necessary elsewhere large groups of citizens have congregated. You are arguing that the etiquette is unconditional while giving solid examples that it is indeed conditional.
Make up your mind.
If others in the bar started standing and singing the national anthem, you’d be a buzz kill and not take part? What a buzz-kill.
You've avoided what I've pointed out quite well, kudos to the sidestepping attempt. You argue people must do so in a group setting, but bars don't count. If bars do not count, then why should anyone participate and why would anyone care if I did or didn't?
I also said it was etiquette and civic custom, something you’ve sidestepped.
But you said bars & the like don't count because:
originally posted by: LesMisanthrope
originally posted by: Deaf Alien
originally posted by: LesMisanthrope
a reply to: ColoradoJens
It’s about doing it with others. The national anthem, and standing for it, is the last customary gesture that binds all the people of the country together. It’s simple etiquette.
So why don't people do it together at bars and homes?
Because they are not where the anthem is being played.
By your own admission, they're not where it's being played, so etiquette and civic customs are completely conditional. Or, in plain English, optional.
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: c2oden
originally posted by: 3NL1GHT3N3D1
a reply to: c2oden
I guess I just choose to not let the state dictate what is right or wrong for me.
How do you feel about North Koreans honoring dear leader out of tradition and being disowned or punished for not toeing the line? Do you think it's fair that they are punished for not bowing down to Kim?
Take a look in the mirror, you're guilty of the same thing except with a flag.
You are missing the point entirely.
It has nothing to do with the "state".
It is about showing respect for something that deserves respect.
It is about respecting what the flag stands for, and honoring those who have fought for which it stands.
It has nothing to do with politics or agendas.
Show some respect.
Those drunk NFL fans who have been tailgating for 12 hours before the game? Is it respectful if you can barely stand?
if you want to call that an anarchist then so be it but that doesn't mean I'm the label you choose to slap on my forehead.
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: c2oden
originally posted by: 3NL1GHT3N3D1
a reply to: c2oden
I guess I just choose to not let the state dictate what is right or wrong for me.
How do you feel about North Koreans honoring dear leader out of tradition and being disowned or punished for not toeing the line? Do you think it's fair that they are punished for not bowing down to Kim?
Take a look in the mirror, you're guilty of the same thing except with a flag.
You are missing the point entirely.
It has nothing to do with the "state".
It is about showing respect for something that deserves respect.
It is about respecting what the flag stands for, and honoring those who have fought for which it stands.
It has nothing to do with politics or agendas.
Show some respect.
Those drunk NFL fans who have been tailgating for 12 hours before the game? Is it respectful if you can barely stand?
originally posted by: 3NL1GHT3N3D1
a reply to: seeker1963
No I'm not an anarchist, I'm my own person who doesn't just throw labels on myself all willy-nilly like. I'm for freedom of expression, if you want to call that an anarchist then so be it but that doesn't mean I'm the label you choose to slap on my forehead.
originally posted by: thesaneone
originally posted by: Deaf Alien
originally posted by: thesaneone
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: thesaneone
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
originally posted by: burdman30ott6
originally posted by: ColoradoJens
Do you stand in your home? If no, you need to look in a mirror and ask why you are such a blatant liar with your feelings. That is unless you never thought about it before, which I would surmise comprises 90% of you or more.
There are a lot of things done in a stadium that nobody does at home, and vise versa. This OP is a horribly poor argument. How many people bow their heads and pray when they see it on TV versus bowing their heads and praying at the dinner table in their home? How many people shoot off fireworks in their living room while watching the 4th of July programming from the major cities? How many people throw slime at their television when watching a live Nickelodian program?
So again the answer is no. Thanks. I'm using this thread and the responses to make another one. I appreciate your input.
So you admit to baiting the members?
Not at all. I asked a simple question. Can you answer it?
Would you believe me?
Would anyone believe the polls?
So that's a no. Thank you.
originally posted by: 3NL1GHT3N3D1
a reply to: c2oden
I think you're missing the point, those veterans fought for my right to sit or stand as I please.
This 97 year old WWII Vet seems to agree with me.
Go on, call him un-American, I dare you.
originally posted by: Deaf Alien
Would anyone believe the polls?