It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by freedish
my understanding is that tongues are useless unless someone can interpret them
Originally posted by junglejake
Originally posted by freedish
my understanding is that tongues are useless unless someone can interpret them
Publicly, no; privately, no. Allow me to explain
In public, speaking tongues without an interpreter present serves a purpose. That purpose, however, is not a good one. It causes folks to think the speaker, and thereby the church, fools, or perhaps just drunkards. (see 1 Cor 14, and perhaps Acts 2). So it serves a purpose to do so in public, just not a purpose towards God's plan. It tends to turn people away from the church.
Yet, in private, in the very same chapter from 1 Corinthians, Paul speaks of tongues in a very positive light, without the emphasis on interpretation. Indeed, the second verse states, "For anyone who speaks in a tongue does not speak to people but to God..."
Obviously, you don't think speaking to God is useless. That's evident by your post. Speaking in tongues in private, or silently, even, seems to be petitioning God via the Holy Spirit living in you. God's word says ask and it will be given you. It also says that whatsoever you pray in Christ's name, so long as it is in His will, will be given you. I don't know about you, but I don't always know (in fact, typically I don't) what God's will is in a situation. The Holy Spirit, on the other hand, I'm confident does. That gift some are given to surrender their will, their prayers, to the Holy Spirit to petition God on some matter they are unaware of or only have vague understanding of, that His will be done in a situation, according to God's Word, will be answered. That is certainly not useless!
In my understanding, it seems there are two elements of the gift of tongues. The one which takes place publicly, correctly, tends to be more prophetic, edifying the church, than petitioning. The private, on the other hand, I've seen give rise to God's moves. Prophesy is more accurate, preaching more poignant and anointed, healing takes place, encouragement and joy pour forth. Even prayer gets more specific. They seem to have two radically different functions, and, unfortunately for many, the private tends to require far more humility than the public. When someone is praying in tongues privately, God is operating through them, but no one this side of Heaven will ever know. When in public, there's no question, typically, that God was operating through you.
Now if we could get past that misunderstanding and realize God's gifts do not denote maturity in the faith, that humility would come a lot more easily!
Originally posted by freedish if you don't understand what your saying then what good does it do? God doesn't need to speak through you via holy spirit to himself. That seems redundant to me. Unless in someway it pleases Him?
My other question is, how do you know if you are truly speaking in tongues via Holy Spirit?
My other question is, how do you know if you are truly speaking in tongues via Holy Spirit?
Assuming you are doing it privately, if you believe you have the gift and turn out to be wrong, you're babbling nonsense to yourself. Big deal. If you believe you have the gift and turn out to be right, who knows what it could bring.
Originally posted by muttkunt
reply to post by Quaght
that was smite my friend ..
as i recall few hundread years back you would be burnt at the stake for being in leauge with the devil for speaking in tounges
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
But also, not all people speak with tongues.
Originally posted by truejew
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
But also, not all people speak with tongues.
Everyone who has received the Holy Spirit has spoke in tongues. It is the initial evidence. The fruit of the Spirit is then the evidence that the person continues to walk in the Spirit.
The gift of tongues is different. Not everyone has the gift of tongues.
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
Originally posted by truejew
Originally posted by NOTurTypical
But also, not all people speak with tongues.
Everyone who has received the Holy Spirit has spoke in tongues. It is the initial evidence. The fruit of the Spirit is then the evidence that the person continues to walk in the Spirit.
The gift of tongues is different. Not everyone has the gift of tongues.
Not all speak in tongues, Paul says this. My gift of the Spirit is prophecy and discernment, not tongues.
edit on 14-9-2012 by NOTurTypical because: (no reason given)