It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: CabablancaHizb
Deuteronomy 32
Sons of God=correct
Sons of Israel=incorrect
originally posted by: CabablancaHizb
a reply to: chr0naut
Israel means "wrestles with God."
Not what you said. It was given to Jacob after wrestling with God and prevailing. You have wrestled with men and with God, and prevailed.
But the literal translation is "wrestles with God.". I think I learned that when I was 12 and the definition you gave is a mockery.
originally posted by: CabablancaHizb
a reply to: chr0naut
I am not arguing about a word I know the definition of. You can quote anything you want like I said that definition you gave is fake, probably deliberately which is not at all uncommon in Judaism.
Your so off on so many things I can't begin to imagine that a conversation with you is of any benefit to me.
God bless.
originally posted by: hounddoghowlie
a reply to: chr0naut
every one of the links on the first page pretty much says, wrestles with God.
none say Sons of God. there are a couple that say could mean God prevails, but seem to lean towards wrestles with God.
originally posted by: hounddoghowlie
a reply to: chr0naut
i hate to say this but in thinking about Genesis 32:22-32, wrestles with God make more sense.
i mean why would God/angle/ or a man call Jacob a son of God after wrestling with him all night.
even if it means God prevails, it was Jacob whose named was changed and he prevailed.
originally posted by: chr0naut
originally posted by: hounddoghowlie
a reply to: chr0naut
i hate to say this but in thinking about Genesis 32:22-32, wrestles with God make more sense.
i mean why would God/angle/ or a man call Jacob a son of God after wrestling with him all night.
even if it means God prevails, it was Jacob whose named was changed and he prevailed.
Yes, that is one of the definitions of the name "Israel".
But the word existed before it was used as a name.
Many believe the word derives from 'sarar' (to rule, be strong or to judge over) and 'El', a word meaning God.
Outside of the Genesis 32 story, the word had the meanings of: "God rules", "God judges", "God prevails" or "God triumphs".
In the context of the Genesis story the meaning is generally agreed to be: "Triumphant with God" or "who prevails with God".
"The Jewish Study Bible" of Oxford University Press says "The scientific etymology of Israel is uncertain, a good guess being '[The God] El rules.'"
originally posted by: CabablancaHizb
originally posted by: chr0naut
originally posted by: hounddoghowlie
a reply to: chr0naut
i hate to say this but in thinking about Genesis 32:22-32, wrestles with God make more sense.
i mean why would God/angle/ or a man call Jacob a son of God after wrestling with him all night.
even if it means God prevails, it was Jacob whose named was changed and he prevailed.
Yes, that is one of the definitions of the name "Israel".
But the word existed before it was used as a name.
That is a total assumption you can't back up.
Many believe the word derives from 'sarar' (to rule, be strong or to judge over) and 'El', a word meaning God.
Outside of the Genesis 32 story, the word had the meanings of: "God rules", "God judges", "God prevails" or "God triumphs".
In the context of the Genesis story the meaning is generally agreed to be: "Triumphant with God" or "who prevails with God".
"The Jewish Study Bible" of Oxford University Press says "The scientific etymology of Israel is uncertain, a good guess being '[The God] El rules.'"
Yeah it means wrestles with God. It is FIRST mentioned after Jacob wrestles with God.
It retains that meaning as a nation and certainly "wrestles" with God to this day. A perfect reason to alter the definition.
But the Biblical definition is what I said.