It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Gryphon66
originally posted by: Granite
originally posted by: dukeofjive696969
Honest question, why are these guys called patriots
The US Constitution is their guiding document...and mine.
What is yours?
Perhaps you and they should read this part then ...
This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in pursuance thereof; and all treaties made, or which shall be made, under the authority of the United States, shall be the supreme law of the land; and the judges in every state shall be bound thereby, anything in the constitution or laws of any state to the contrary notwithstanding.
(Article VI, Clause 2)
Emphasis mine. Words courtesy of James Madison and the Constitutional Convention.
Going against your government is not patriotism, its called treason.
"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed."
everyone there should be locked up
Why is it that the bundys can get away with taking over government buildings, owing millions of dollars in grazing fees
and not to mention trying to go to war with the government,pointing guns and threatening to kill federal agents.
But Edward Snowden leaked information about the government spying on americans and he (Snowden) is the one facing jail time if not worse if he returns to the states.
but these bundy hillbilly rejects get to stay free?
how can anyone think they can win against the federal govt? serious question. now they're destroying federal property? are they trying to taunt the feds? like i said before, it looks like they're trying to start trouble, if they keep it up they will get it. id rather live than to die proving a point. you can romanticise martyrdom, but in the end you are either dead or alive.
So when the government breaks the laws and abuses it's power, we Americans should let them, correct?
“This is NOT a standoff with BLM. We are NOT promoting any confrontation with BLM. This is a security operation for the protection of Constitutional Rights.”
originally posted by: machineintelligence
a reply to: xuenchen
It is a matter of survival for these folks. When people see big ranches they think wealthy people but a lot like any farmer they can lose everything in one or two bad seasons but the BLM is terrorizing these people. Here is a good back story so some people will I hope get a clue.
originally posted by: Informer1958
a reply to: vjr1113
how can anyone think they can win against the federal govt? serious question. now they're destroying federal property? are they trying to taunt the feds? like i said before, it looks like they're trying to start trouble, if they keep it up they will get it. id rather live than to die proving a point. you can romanticise martyrdom, but in the end you are either dead or alive.
So when the government breaks the laws and abuses it's power, we Americans should let them, correct?
When your government become Tyrannical, what should Americans do?
the very same Constitution and Bill of Rights gives us the green light to overthrow a tyrannical govt...And that is the major reason for the ability to bear (bare) arms , right ? . Of course , you may not. In the above case , ti is neither sedition nor treason. But a right.
originally posted by: Gothmog
originally posted by: clay2 baraka
originally posted by: snypwsd
a reply to: machineintelligence
Going against your government is not patriotism, its called treason. everyone there should be locked up. Why is it that the bundys can get away with taking over government buildings, owing millions of dollars in grazing fees and not to mention trying to go to war with the government,pointing guns and threatening to kill federal agents. But Edward Snowden leaked information about the government spying on americans and he (Snowden) is the one facing jail time if not worse if he returns to the states. but these bundy hillbilly rejects get to stay free?
America makes no sense.
Technically, it's not treason. It's sedition.
You did know that the very same Constitution and Bill of Rights gives us the green light to overthrow a tyrannical govt...And that is the major reason for the ability to bear (bare) arms , right ? . Of course , you may not.
In the above case , ti is neither sedition nor treason. But a right.
originally posted by: Subaeruginosa
a reply to: Informer1958
If there was any truth to what your claiming, then why aren't these people protesting outside land that has been forcibly brought by the government for mining purposes? They wouldn't even need a gun to do it, just block off the entrance and shut down the mining operation.
Instead, they're occupying a Federal wildlife refuge and demanding the Government allow grazing and logging on it... which I might add, is against the wishes of the majority of locals and even the local native Americans.
originally posted by: yesyesyes
originally posted by: Gothmog
originally posted by: clay2 baraka
originally posted by: snypwsd
a reply to: machineintelligence
Going against your government is not patriotism, its called treason. everyone there should be locked up. Why is it that the bundys can get away with taking over government buildings, owing millions of dollars in grazing fees and not to mention trying to go to war with the government,pointing guns and threatening to kill federal agents. But Edward Snowden leaked information about the government spying on americans and he (Snowden) is the one facing jail time if not worse if he returns to the states. but these bundy hillbilly rejects get to stay free?
America makes no sense.
Technically, it's not treason. It's sedition.
You did know that the very same Constitution and Bill of Rights gives us the green light to overthrow a tyrannical govt...And that is the major reason for the ability to bear (bare) arms , right ? . Of course , you may not.
In the above case , ti is neither sedition nor treason. But a right.
These men are not acting out of patriotism, they are acting out of naked self interest.
If this land reverts, it should go to the First Nations people, period.
What laws has BLM broken? I'd really like to know.
The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) acted illegally when it dispatched armed rangers to remove Cliven Bundy’s cattle from federal land in Clark County, Nevada, a Congressman is charging.
The BLM’s action led to a standoff between armed protestors and authorities that attracted national media attention.
“Because of this standoff, I have looked into BLM’s authority to conduct such paramilitary raids against American citizens, and it appears that BLM is acting in a lawless manner in Nevada,” Rep. Steve Stockman (R-Texas) wrote in a letter to President Obama, the Secretary of the Interior and the Director of the BLM.
Stockman contends that Section 1733 of the United States Code requires the BLM rely on local law enforcement officers to enforce regulations rather than its own rangers. He also alleged that the BLM refused to work with the Clark County Sheriff’s Office in its actions against Bundy.
Sheriff on the Sidelines?
“Under this statute, whenever the Secretary of the Interior determines that force may be necessary to secure obedience to federal law and regulation, the Secretary must seek the cooperation of local law enforcement officials,” Stockman wrote.
Ron Paul Gets Involved
Stockman, who just lost a US Senate primary race in Texas, is not the only prominent politician from that state to take an interest in the Bundy affair. Former Congressman and presidential candidate Ron Paul is also questioning the BLM’s authority.
In this case it’s who should own the land,” Paul said of the Bundy dispute. The trouble developed because most of the land in Nevada is federally owned and controlled by the BLM. He noted that such disputes would be unlikely in states like Texas where most of the land is privately owned.
“They had virtual ownership of that land because they had been using it,” Paul told Fox News’ Neil Cavuto. The Bundies have been grazing cattle in the area for a century. “I think land should be in the states and they should sell it to the people.”
“You need the government out of it,” Paul said of land ownership. Paul suggested that the federal government transfer all the land in the West to the states.
Paul predicted that there will be more such disputes in the future because he thinks the economy is getting worse. In particular, he believes there will be more disputes between the BLM and ranchers.
The Secretary may authorize Federal personnel or appropriate local officials to carry out his law enforcement responsibilities with respect to the public lands and their resources.
Nothing in this Act shall be construed as reducing or limiting the enforcement authority vested in the Secretary by any other statute.
originally posted by: Teikiatsu
originally posted by: Gryphon66
originally posted by: Granite
originally posted by: dukeofjive696969
Honest question, why are these guys called patriots
The US Constitution is their guiding document...and mine.
What is yours?
Perhaps you and they should read this part then ...
This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in pursuance thereof; and all treaties made, or which shall be made, under the authority of the United States, shall be the supreme law of the land; and the judges in every state shall be bound thereby, anything in the constitution or laws of any state to the contrary notwithstanding.
(Article VI, Clause 2)
Emphasis mine. Words courtesy of James Madison and the Constitutional Convention.
When some people think the laws and lawmakers are bad and/or corrupt, those people will ignore and break the law.
DOMA and DADT were the law of the land at one time. That didn't stop people from ignoring, breaking, or refusing to uphold them.