It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Answer
Whenever I see "former NASA engineer claims...", I immediately dismiss it as a hoax.
That particular title may impress some people but the reality is, "former NASA engineer" means absolutely nothing. The guy could have worked at NASA for a week designing a new barf bag and now he can claim he's a "former NASA engineer."
So your hypothesis is that the story was fabricated and planted in an obscure newspaper clipping
so that THIRTY YEARS LATER when McClelland began publicly telling his stories, somebody would FIND the article and use it to discredit him falsely
originally posted by: artistpoet
a reply to: JimOberg
So your hypothesis is that the story was fabricated and planted in an obscure newspaper clipping
I have no such hypothesis ... I just understand that we should not take what the media reports as proven fact ...
But then it logically follows that you can't take what McClellend says as proven fact, either.
So then we are left with analyzing and considering this report only on its merits, and without any evidence whatsoever confirming McClellend's story, there is absolutely no way I would be able to believe his story as being true.
Sure -- it hasn't been disproved either, so I suppose it is still "within the realm of possibility", but I will chose to think that McClellend is just after the publicity in order to get people to visit his website to buy his expensive book and expensive trinkets.
Therefore, considering that he runs a website in which he tries to sell his overpriced book and overpriced trinkets, I will chose to think that McClellend is just after the publicity in order to get people to visit that website to buy that book and trinkets
originally posted by: artistpoet
I have no opinion but can see why he needs to make money also
However, that's just one more piece of this that makes me think he may be spinning a wild fictional story just so he can profit from it. I could be wrong about that, but that's how it appears to me.
originally posted by: JimOberg
originally posted by: McGinty
a reply to: onebigmonkey
My point is a general one that more and more people are trusting google to tell them the truth. Have you looked through all the old newspaper archives that may have had other stories on this individual?
I certainly haven't, it's a pretty big task to physically go to all those libraries and do that....
Some ufologists have been collecting clippings for decades. Now do we have to believe some midnight PTB raiders came into our houses and STOLE those particular clippings and erased their titles from our logs?
I did not find those clippings from google, I clipped them from the paper in 1981. How many mental gymnastics will you invent to evade the significance of that?
originally posted by: Andromedabound
For all those 'pics or it didn't happen' people out there... he has plenty of pics! (At least placing him at NASA)
I think this guy is telling the truth - like most others who have done the same, his record has been wiped and he has lost his financial security. He is not the first NASA employee to make claims, far from it.
originally posted by: Andromedabound
... his record has been wiped and he has lost his financial security. He is not the first NASA employee to make claims, far from it.