It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: MimiSia
a reply to: BlueMule
oh I don't get u either
didn't cristianity begin later
but they marked Jesus's birth as the start??
is anyone disputing Jesus was Jew ???
sorry language barrier pls expand
I dispute that Jesus ever lived. As a mythological figure he was a Jew, of course.
If he did live, he epitomized the psychological process that a mystic undergoes.
If he didn't live, his story was written by people who understood that process. Only mystics understand that process.
Only mystics grok the gospel.
So, the distinction is meaningless. It doesn't matter whether he lived or not. I would have expected you to realize that, given your love of religious scholarship.
/shrug
👣
It certainly does matter within the context of Christianity whether he lived because it is a foundational belief of CHristianity that he died to "save us", etc.. It doesn't matter within the context of this thread so I wonder why you brought it up to begin with?
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: MimiSia
a reply to: BlueMule
oh I don't get u either
didn't cristianity begin later
but they marked Jesus's birth as the start??
is anyone disputing Jesus was Jew ???
sorry language barrier pls expand
I dispute that Jesus ever lived. As a mythological figure he was a Jew, of course.
If he did live, he epitomized the psychological process that a mystic undergoes.
If he didn't live, his story was written by people who understood that process. Only mystics understand that process.
Only mystics grok the gospel.
So, the distinction is meaningless. It doesn't matter whether he lived or not. I would have expected you to realize that, given your love of religious scholarship.
/shrug
👣
It certainly does matter within the context of Christianity whether he lived because it is a foundational belief of CHristianity that he died to "save us", etc.. It doesn't matter within the context of this thread so I wonder why you brought it up to begin with?
Within the context of exoteric Christianity, not esoteric Christianity. Which do you think a mystic such as Jesus would point to?
👣
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: MimiSia
a reply to: BlueMule
oh I don't get u either
didn't cristianity begin later
but they marked Jesus's birth as the start??
is anyone disputing Jesus was Jew ???
sorry language barrier pls expand
I dispute that Jesus ever lived. As a mythological figure he was a Jew, of course.
If he did live, he epitomized the psychological process that a mystic undergoes.
If he didn't live, his story was written by people who understood that process. Only mystics understand that process.
Only mystics grok the gospel.
So, the distinction is meaningless. It doesn't matter whether he lived or not. I would have expected you to realize that, given your love of religious scholarship.
/shrug
👣
It certainly does matter within the context of Christianity whether he lived because it is a foundational belief of CHristianity that he died to "save us", etc.. It doesn't matter within the context of this thread so I wonder why you brought it up to begin with?
Within the context of exoteric Christianity, not esoteric Christianity. Which do you think a mystic such as Jesus would point to?
👣
Imaginary people don't point.
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: MimiSia
a reply to: BlueMule
oh I don't get u either
didn't cristianity begin later
but they marked Jesus's birth as the start??
is anyone disputing Jesus was Jew ???
sorry language barrier pls expand
I dispute that Jesus ever lived. As a mythological figure he was a Jew, of course.
If he did live, he epitomized the psychological process that a mystic undergoes.
If he didn't live, his story was written by people who understood that process. Only mystics understand that process.
Only mystics grok the gospel.
So, the distinction is meaningless. It doesn't matter whether he lived or not. I would have expected you to realize that, given your love of religious scholarship.
/shrug
👣
It certainly does matter within the context of Christianity whether he lived because it is a foundational belief of CHristianity that he died to "save us", etc.. It doesn't matter within the context of this thread so I wonder why you brought it up to begin with?
Within the context of exoteric Christianity, not esoteric Christianity. Which do you think a mystic such as Jesus would point to?
👣
Imaginary people don't point.
But you aren't imaginary. So why are you trying to destroy the faith of Christians, instead of pointing them to the esoteric?
I can only conclude it's because you don't grok the esoteric. You are no mystic.
👣
originally posted by: MimiSia
a reply to: BlueMule
honest ...I don't get u what are u disputing ? lol
everything ?
anyway the basic question here is (tell me if i am wrong ) do occults (the top one hundred seem meaningful, normal and ok to be a part of ? yes or no?
originally posted by: MimiSia
a reply to: BlueMule
honest ...I don't get u what are u disputing ? lol
everything ?
anyway the basic question here is (tell me if i am wrong ) do occults (the top one hundred seem meaningful, normal and ok to be a part of ? yes or no?
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: MimiSia
a reply to: BlueMule
oh I don't get u either
didn't cristianity begin later
but they marked Jesus's birth as the start??
is anyone disputing Jesus was Jew ???
sorry language barrier pls expand
I dispute that Jesus ever lived. As a mythological figure he was a Jew, of course.
If he did live, he epitomized the psychological process that a mystic undergoes.
If he didn't live, his story was written by people who understood that process. Only mystics understand that process.
Only mystics grok the gospel.
So, the distinction is meaningless. It doesn't matter whether he lived or not. I would have expected you to realize that, given your love of religious scholarship.
/shrug
👣
It certainly does matter within the context of Christianity whether he lived because it is a foundational belief of CHristianity that he died to "save us", etc.. It doesn't matter within the context of this thread so I wonder why you brought it up to begin with?
Within the context of exoteric Christianity, not esoteric Christianity. Which do you think a mystic such as Jesus would point to?
👣
Imaginary people don't point.
But you aren't imaginary. So why are you trying to destroy the faith of Christians, instead of pointing them to the esoteric?
I can only conclude it's because you don't grok the esoteric. You are no mystic.
👣
I am not interested in proselytizing. Discussing the esoteric with literalists is an utter waste of time. You know that.
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: MimiSia
a reply to: BlueMule
oh I don't get u either
didn't cristianity begin later
but they marked Jesus's birth as the start??
is anyone disputing Jesus was Jew ???
sorry language barrier pls expand
I dispute that Jesus ever lived. As a mythological figure he was a Jew, of course.
If he did live, he epitomized the psychological process that a mystic undergoes.
If he didn't live, his story was written by people who understood that process. Only mystics understand that process.
Only mystics grok the gospel.
So, the distinction is meaningless. It doesn't matter whether he lived or not. I would have expected you to realize that, given your love of religious scholarship.
/shrug
👣
It certainly does matter within the context of Christianity whether he lived because it is a foundational belief of CHristianity that he died to "save us", etc.. It doesn't matter within the context of this thread so I wonder why you brought it up to begin with?
Within the context of exoteric Christianity, not esoteric Christianity. Which do you think a mystic such as Jesus would point to?
👣
Imaginary people don't point.
But you aren't imaginary. So why are you trying to destroy the faith of Christians, instead of pointing them to the esoteric?
I can only conclude it's because you don't grok the esoteric. You are no mystic.
👣
I am not interested in proselytizing. Discussing the esoteric with literalists is an utter waste of time. You know that.
No, I don't know that. What I do know, is that I used to be a fundamentalist. Now I am an esoteric mystic. I also know that efforts like yours to destroy my faith didn't work.
I doubt you truly grok the esoteric, therefore I doubt you are capable of discussing it with literalists.
👣
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: MimiSia
a reply to: BlueMule
oh I don't get u either
didn't cristianity begin later
but they marked Jesus's birth as the start??
is anyone disputing Jesus was Jew ???
sorry language barrier pls expand
I dispute that Jesus ever lived. As a mythological figure he was a Jew, of course.
If he did live, he epitomized the psychological process that a mystic undergoes.
If he didn't live, his story was written by people who understood that process. Only mystics understand that process.
Only mystics grok the gospel.
So, the distinction is meaningless. It doesn't matter whether he lived or not. I would have expected you to realize that, given your love of religious scholarship.
/shrug
👣
It certainly does matter within the context of Christianity whether he lived because it is a foundational belief of CHristianity that he died to "save us", etc.. It doesn't matter within the context of this thread so I wonder why you brought it up to begin with?
Within the context of exoteric Christianity, not esoteric Christianity. Which do you think a mystic such as Jesus would point to?
👣
Imaginary people don't point.
But you aren't imaginary. So why are you trying to destroy the faith of Christians, instead of pointing them to the esoteric?
I can only conclude it's because you don't grok the esoteric. You are no mystic.
👣
I am not interested in proselytizing. Discussing the esoteric with literalists is an utter waste of time. You know that.
No, I don't know that. What I do know, is that I used to be a fundamentalist. Now I am an esoteric mystic. I also know that efforts like yours to destroy my faith didn't work.
I doubt you truly grok the esoteric, therefore I doubt you are capable of discussing it with literalists.
👣
I don't delude myself into thinking that my efforts will persuade fundamentalists to change their minds. However, pointing out the utter absurdity and illogic of their beliefs and their inability to defend those beliefs does sometimes make an impression with non-fundamentalists who read these posts. It also serves the purpose of encouraging others to stand up and speak out against fundamentalism which is really just a totalitarian political movement.
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: BlueMule
originally posted by: Tangerine
originally posted by: MimiSia
a reply to: BlueMule
oh I don't get u either
didn't cristianity begin later
but they marked Jesus's birth as the start??
is anyone disputing Jesus was Jew ???
sorry language barrier pls expand
I dispute that Jesus ever lived. As a mythological figure he was a Jew, of course.
If he did live, he epitomized the psychological process that a mystic undergoes.
If he didn't live, his story was written by people who understood that process. Only mystics understand that process.
Only mystics grok the gospel.
So, the distinction is meaningless. It doesn't matter whether he lived or not. I would have expected you to realize that, given your love of religious scholarship.
/shrug
👣
It certainly does matter within the context of Christianity whether he lived because it is a foundational belief of CHristianity that he died to "save us", etc.. It doesn't matter within the context of this thread so I wonder why you brought it up to begin with?
Within the context of exoteric Christianity, not esoteric Christianity. Which do you think a mystic such as Jesus would point to?
👣
Imaginary people don't point.
But you aren't imaginary. So why are you trying to destroy the faith of Christians, instead of pointing them to the esoteric?
I can only conclude it's because you don't grok the esoteric. You are no mystic.
👣
I am not interested in proselytizing. Discussing the esoteric with literalists is an utter waste of time. You know that.
No, I don't know that. What I do know, is that I used to be a fundamentalist. Now I am an esoteric mystic. I also know that efforts like yours to destroy my faith didn't work.
I doubt you truly grok the esoteric, therefore I doubt you are capable of discussing it with literalists.
👣
I don't delude myself into thinking that my efforts will persuade fundamentalists to change their minds. However, pointing out the utter absurdity and illogic of their beliefs and their inability to defend those beliefs does sometimes make an impression with non-fundamentalists who read these posts. It also serves the purpose of encouraging others to stand up and speak out against fundamentalism which is really just a totalitarian political movement.
The shortest path from Christian fundamentalism is Christian mysticism, not the utter defeat of atheism. You are going about it all wrong. And your trolling is pissing me off.
👣