It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Phage
a reply to: Aquariusdude
Did you read the links?
Was there a leak saying what the Manhattan project was about?
But we aren't talking about all the "details", are we?
originally posted by: peck420
So...all the amateur astronomers in on the secret? Hell, the pro's from other countries?
Radio operators?
Everybody engaged in power transmission?
These are all people that would be well aware of anything in our neighborhood producing enough energy to 'travel the stars'.
Nobody is space traveling in secret. Anybody that thinks so is blissfully unaware of what it would take to make that travel possible, and just how visible it would be from the planet. To give you a good idea...using the latest materials (most of which aren't even being produced by the scientists that invented them yet, let alone top secret military programs) the craft required to travel the stars would be easily visible, by the human eye...on the ground.
originally posted by: MrJohnSmith
It just would'nt be possible to keep advanced technology secret, too many people would be working on it, human nature being what it is.
.
originally posted by: BASSPLYR
I think its a little strange that all the references of Ben Rich saying all of this stuff come from second hand sources but none have any direct quotes. Seems like wishful thinking by the UFO crowd.
I agree with Phages assessment.
That being said. I do know we have something that's waaaaaaaay beyond a new black project steath bomber or aurora flying around. I've seen it. I have no proof and even if I did I sure as hell wouldn't post it publicly ever. But I can assure you we do indeed have something extremely advanced and exotic. I however have no idea if it is capable of interstellar travel or even high altitude orbit. But it's very, very advanced.
But even I say the Ben Rich quotes are bunk. That being said Ben definitely knew more about the subject then probably most out there. But he also seemed like the type to keep a secret that amazing all the way to his grave.
originally posted by: Aquariusdude
How would amateur astronomers pick up on secret space craft? look at the stealth bomber at night is it detectable with optics or the naked eye? No its not its not like these craft would be operating with there lights on.
Also how would radio operators pick up on most likely highly encrypted transmissions? you would need the super computing power of the NSA probably to crack those..your average radio ham operator would not have the power to do this. And I don't get power transmissions.
originally posted by: peck420
originally posted by: Aquariusdude
How would amateur astronomers pick up on secret space craft? look at the stealth bomber at night is it detectable with optics or the naked eye? No its not its not like these craft would be operating with there lights on.
X-37 was tracked from the first launch until today, by amateur astronomers. And, if you think that anything we can build with our latest tech is going to be that small...lol...the current SMALLEST designs are magnitudes larger than the X-37.
Also how would radio operators pick up on most likely highly encrypted transmissions? you would need the super computing power of the NSA probably to crack those..your average radio ham operator would not have the power to do this. And I don't get power transmissions.
You don't get it because you are completely unaware of the power requirements. It's not going to be a couple chemical booster, we are talking petajoules of energy required. This is around the same amount of energy released by the Tsar Bomb (to get us to crawl speed in spacial terms)...it will be noticed.
As for the power transmission lines, they will notice for the same reason that they notice solar flares.
originally posted by: Zaphod58
a reply to: Aquariusdude
Encrypted or not, there is still something to pick up. That's why the B-2 and other stealth aircraft have their antennas retracted into the fuselage before they go into combat. Not only would it cause a bigger cross section on radar, but if they were to transmit, or someone to transmit to them, it could be picked up and located, giving away their position. You don't have to crack them to be able to locate them, and triangulate them.
originally posted by: Aquariusdude
It is white so it will reflect light and is easily detectable in orbit we can assume if there is a super secret space program there craft would be black like a stealth bomber...also how do we know what the requirements for energy are when we don't know anything about the technology?
originally posted by: Zaphod58
a reply to: Aquariusdude
If you know the approximate launch angle of the rocket, you can figure out the orbital angle, and eventually figure out about where and when it should be overhead.