It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Those observations were not cognizant of things like the placebo effect, and the subsequent need for double blind studies. The placebo effect can actually be observed, so it's not totally an illusion, but it can lead to making observations which are misleading. Even today when modern science knows about the placebo effect, it's apparent many people continue to overlook this phenomenon with their anecdotes and other conclusions based on observations which don't consider this effect.
originally posted by: Andromedabound
reply to: Arbitrageur
FYI science has been around for thousands of years through "observation and experiment".
It's a juice diet, and especially in the context of this thread which is about a real fast, it's not a real fast.
In a juice fast you are denying the body of protein for a short period which allows the body to switch from 'growth mode' to 'repair mode'.
The word you seek is not "fast", it is "diet".
So yes, it is a fast, as we are fasting from calories, protein and fat.[/quote]
I've got no argument against caloric restriction, but I don't think a 100% juice diet is a balanced diet. I think it's possible to limit caloric consumption with a more balanced and healthy intake of calories. I suspect eating the actual fruit will have more fiber than the juice and is therefore healthier than just consuming the juice, and other nutrients in a more balanced diet can be consumed without over-consumption.
"Significant caloric restriction is the one and only thing that has been scientifically proven to extend life span," said Hellerstein
Fasting for three days can regenerate entire immune system, study finds
.....Study Finds.....
originally posted by: Andromedabound
reply to: Arbitrageur
In a juice fast you are denying the body of protein for a short period
Studies over the past 70 years have established that substantial calorie reduction - up to 50 percent in some studies - not only can reduce the rate of cell proliferation, it can extend the maximum life span of a variety of organisms, including rats, flies, worms and yeast. The results can be dramatic, with 30 to 70 percent increases in life span reported in the studies.
Cutting calories has also been shown to reduce the development of cancer, enhance insulin sensitivity and lower the risk of heart disease.