It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
LittleByLittle
If you do not seek the source behind religion then you will not find the source of religion. And I am not talking about faith but I am talking about spiritual experience thru tools like meditation where you get to know the source of religions. To test yourself what is without preconceived notions of "what is".
tsingtao
Toadmund
reply to post by LittleByLittle
You are assuming there is a god, of which proof is sorely lacking.
We have free will because most likely there is no God to stop us doing as we will.
'God gave us free will' , just another excuse for make believe reality.
sounds like YOU assume that because you have free will there is no God and IF there was, everything would be hunky-dory all day long.
my coffee cup doesn't have free will, it does what i tell it. in the morning you hold coffee, at night maybe a beer.
do people expect to be coffee cups if there was a god, in their minds?
who wants to be a coffee cup?
Toadmund
One could take your quote here and realise that the source of religion came from the minds of men.
Certain substances have told me personally that the brain is a much more amazing thing than most people can't even begin to realise. Most people have no clue the power they can witness to it.
But how much of that transends ones own mind?
I-doh-no?!
AfterInfinity
reply to post by Toadmund
No, that's not a straw man. Tsingtao raises an excellent point. From the way I've heard it, a teacup is actually the kindest label I can think of for the way we'd exist. If the teacup doesn't appeal to his decorative tastes or isn't the right size or maybe spills some tea on him one day, he discards it. It is no longer a teacup, in his eyes. It is garbage. And if we are not his, we are worse than refuse. We are the stinking waste of his exquisite universe. Or something like that. I once described the basic nature of free will in the presence of a divine creator. There is none. The creator cannot be all-powerful and all-knowing and still not be responsible for literally ever moment and every inch of existence from one end to the other. And we're assuming those are prerequisites of being a creator, right?
jazz10
Because I'm here.
Toadmund
tsingtao
Toadmund
reply to post by LittleByLittle
You are assuming there is a god, of which proof is sorely lacking.
We have free will because most likely there is no God to stop us doing as we will.
'God gave us free will' , just another excuse for make believe reality.
sounds like YOU assume that because you have free will there is no God and IF there was, everything would be hunky-dory all day long.
my coffee cup doesn't have free will, it does what i tell it. in the morning you hold coffee, at night maybe a beer.
do people expect to be coffee cups if there was a god, in their minds?
who wants to be a coffee cup?
AfterInfinity
reply to post by Toadmund
No, that's not a straw man. Tsingtao raises an excellent point. From the way I've heard it, a teacup is actually the kindest label I can think of for the way we'd exist. If the teacup doesn't appeal to his decorative tastes or isn't the right size or maybe spills some tea on him one day, he discards it. It is no longer a teacup, in his eyes. It is garbage. And if we are not his, we are worse than refuse. We are the stinking waste of his exquisite universe. Or something like that. I once described the basic nature of free will in the presence of a divine creator. There is none. The creator cannot be all-powerful and all-knowing and still not be responsible for literally ever moment and every inch of existence from one end to the other. And we're assuming those are prerequisites of being a creator, right?
neoholographic
I believe in a Creator and I think the best evidence of a Creator is us. We're the Creator having local experiences. This is what we do, we Create.
Also, the question who Created the Creator is a silly one. In order to ask this question you first have to define a creator that's bound by the laws of physics we experience in a 3 dimensional universe. Why would a Creator that I believe in need to be created?
So when an atheist asks me this question, I simply ask how do they define Creator? If they don't believe in a Creator then how are they defining the term Creator in the question that they're asking?
thedeadtruth
Universal truths are normally simple.
People believe in a creator because it is easy and takes no effort. It is all laid out for you . No thinking required. Just believe, never ask.
The alternative is a lifetime of asking questions, all the time knowing you will die and never understand 1% of anything.
Most people flow like water down the easiest path.
hey, thanks. God made you, didn't He? at least every ancestor that you know of. right?