It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
I'm a pharmacology student in my third (and final) year; I plan on going for a masters and a Ph.D too after I've finished that. Also I never mentioned if the structural changes was present in 100% of cases.
I am aware that there are other theories as to why it develops, I was just listing the ones that have a fair bit of evidence to back them up (pharmacologically speaking). As we progress in the field of medicine, we will find out more and more answers. Hopefully some time in the near future we will determine the exact cause of schizophrenia. I have no idea how many identical twins have been studied, I don't know why that's relevant.
There is no medical test for schizophrenia, the only way to diagnose someone is to interview the person or members of his/her family to see if they have any of the symptoms. The more of them that person has, the more likely they are to have schizophrenia. After that the doctor can perform a ct/mri of the brain to see if there are any other changes to the structure of the brain (i.e. similar to the pictures I posted previously), this rules out any other possible diseases.
Similarly there is no chemical test to determine the cause of chemical imbalance of the brain (that's not to say we won't discover one in the future)
'Psychiatry is to medicine what astrology is to astronomy.' -- Leonard Roy Frank
I presume by this you mean that psychiatry is a load of nonsense?
A psychotic person may have a thought of a butterfly and think he is literally the thought. The spiritual state of consciousness does not identity itself with the thinking brain which is simply Witnessed as something arising.
Adi Da had the look of Infinity in His Eyes. He did not appear to be an Other. The experience was not lacking anything. I felt a tremendous electric like energy descend my spine, making my weak nerves so overpowered that it was difficult to stand. I was in the presence of God.
Originally posted by Throwback
reply to post by christina-66
You found 2 of the many symptoms of schizophrenia. Sarcasm aside, I guess I never considered those passages to be hallucinations and delusions. I stand corrected. Interesting point of view. Actually, I never even thought about voices they heard. I just kind of accepted it as a mystical phenomenon I guess.
Originally posted by christina-66
Precisely – diagnoses made on the basis of observation and subjective opinion alone. There is no proof – none – that this is a biological/genetic disorder – no matter what your textbooks tell you.
This is an outright lie. We clearly see that statistically, siblings of those with schizophrenia have a much higher chance of developing the disorder. Take the case of two identical twins who live in different families. If one develops it, the others chance of acquiring the illness is around 50%. OBVIOUSLY, this is because there's a genetic component to it.
All the same, just because certain genetics give a higher propensity for the disease to manifest, it doesn't mean there isn't an environmental component as well. I think we've digressed in our understanding of mental illness. You said that 100 years ago people thought mental illness was in the gut. It seems to me they were much more on target than we are more recently.
Originally posted by christina-66
You call me a liar in one paragraph - and then contradict yourself in the second - and then you agree with me!!!
Mathew 1Then was Jesus led up of the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted of the devil. 2And when he had fasted forty days and forty nights, he was afterward an hungred. 3And when the tempter came to him, he said, If thou be the Son of God, command that these stones be made bread. 4But he answered and said, It is written, Man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God.
Originally posted by christina-66
I dunno – these people all seemed to be observing their experience with some fascination.
That sounds like a real transformative experience. Did it stay with you?
You cant learn this from a few posts. You need to read The Knee of Listening and the Method of the Siddhas.
You complain about the other posters arguments, but you would rather argue than read also. This is your resistance to the Truth.
You can only tell if a person is spiritual intuitively and you can only tell if a person is SZ intuitively. Symptoms are not definitive.
I have been studying SZ for 45 years. I have not seen any credible evidence that it can be cured by nutrition. If it could be then there would be millions of cures for reference. (Acute Psychosis may be different.) And I believe the evidence points points to a bio chemical disorder, genetically related,as being the most likely cause. However currently there are no drugs that can cure this.My theory is that once the brain, due to this bio chemical disorder enters in the SZ state it is like a tape loop that is very rarely broken.
The mentally ill are having a perfectly normal response to an abnormal and unnatural world. So in essence the ones deemed mentally ill are perfectly mentally healthy. They are responding correctly to the enviroment.
Originally posted by christina-66
I have said that I have taken a look at his book and that would take time to read. It does not make a connection for me
I wouldn’t say I’m complaining about the other posters arguments I’d say I was countering any argument that holds schizophrenia to be a ‘proven’ genetic/biological condition. Which it is not in my experience.
A person going through a full blown psychotic break is patently obvious. The cause of that break has to be investigated, which presently, it is not. but argue that medication should only ever be used in the short term not for life.
People are not all the same. There are different causes and thus different solutions – possibly for each individual.
Freed of responsibility Mr & Mrs Lunatic were ‘at it like rabbits’ and producing many offspring whereas Mr & Mrs Normal were working hard to provide for their family.
The Victorians came along and said enough of this. The inherited theory was even around in those days and so they built the asylum. The Victorians reckoned that within a generation or two lunatics and natural born fools would simply die out. But they did not. Come the 1940’s and 1950’s lunatics and natural born fools were still being admitted from the ‘normal’ population.
That is why you have not heard of nutrition helping people. Not only nutrition – but investigating the key stressors that triggered the distress in the patient in the first instance isn’t considered.
I too have posted reading material on this thread. Perhaps the most important being ‘Anatomy of an Epidemic: The Astonishing Rise of Mental Illness in America’.
I would ask that you please take a look at this essay RRokkyy.
Children who have two parents with schizophrenia run an extremely high risk of developing the disorder themselves. Irving I. Gottesman, PhD., Hon. F.R.C. Psych., of the University of Minnesota Medical School in Minneapolis, and his colleagues looked at 2.7 million individuals born in Denmark. Their study method matched population records in a general registry with records of psychiatric hospital admissions. Specifically looked for were patients whose parents both had admissions to psychiatric facilities for schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. They compared rates of psychiatric admissions for these people to those of offspring with one or no parent admitted to facilities. Not surprisingly, rates of schizophrenia were the highest among children of two parents with a schizophrenia diagnosis. The numbers were alarming. Of the 196 couples with schizophrenia, 27.3 percent of their 270 offspring were admitted to a psychiatric facility. This number then increased to 39.2 percent when schizophrenia spectrum disorders were included. This compared with a 7 percent rate among 13,878 offspring of 8,006 couples in which one parent had schizophrenia and 0.86 percent in 2.2 million offspring of 1 million couples in which neither parent had a psychiatric admission.
There can only be one explanation for consciousness or reality.
The study below clearly PROVES a genetic link to SZ.
This is very disturbing. It sounds like you what you
are selling is individual psychotherapy,highly priced
for maximum profit. Every person must have their own personal therapist.
They were partially correct. If schizophrenics were to have a high breeding rate the country would be overrun with them. People with SZ should not have
children except through AI or Invitro with donor gametes.
Originally posted by christina-66
It skips a generation sometimes. Thats what happened with my mother and her sisters and brothers.
People have a near complete bias (brainwashing) against the idea that anything dealing with the brain or personality can be inherited; IQ,Musical talent,artistic talent,linguistic ability,personality,mental illness.
Yet every statistic points to that.
You can inherit your parents blonde hair and blue eyes but you cant inherit the shape and structure of their brains because that would mean you are like an ANIMAL and the product
of breeding.