It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by freedish
reply to post by thewholepicture
Jews and Christians worship the same God. Although Jews don't seem to believe that Jesus was God.
Muslims are way off base. I truly think that's a doctrine of devils.
Here's the problem with Judaism.
You can never be good enough for God. You can never follow the law well enough and get into Heaven.
Everyone falls short of the glory of God. It's so simple- that's why we NEED a saviour, Jesus!
I'm not too sure about Islam- but unless it teaches that we can't get to Heaven by our own deeds, an that Jesus is the son of God, it is wrong. Sorry if that seems closed minded.
Originally posted by thewholepicture
So what do you think?
Originally posted by trailertrash
reply to post by thewholepicture
Well all three of those religions keep saying there is only one God so how could it be otherwise?
I mean, if one group worshiped a false god the other two groups would have to admit the existence of two gods, one true and one false. So the answer must be yes. If only one of those religions worshiped the true god and the other two false ones then there would have to be three gods, one true and two false. So the answer must be yes.
False or true whatever gods exist all have to be counted and tallied up.
By the way both Judaism and Islam claim all three religions worship the same God. It is Christianity which stands alone with their obnoxious statements to the contrary. Why is it always the Christians who seem so damned determined to make life miserable for other religions? They should leave others alone and mind their own sins for a change.
One of the reasons Christianity gets such a bad rap in the world is because so many other peoples in foreign lands are happy and content with their own religions and resent outsiders coming in and suggesting to them that the things they believe are false.
Religion is personal and private for each of us. God has no religious preference. So long as people behave themselves God doesn't give a fig what religion they belong to.
Now watch the Christians howl and complain about that.... They always complain about something.edit on 18-12-2010 by trailertrash because: (no reason given)edit on 18-12-2010 by trailertrash because: (no reason given)
Originally posted by Subhuti
I think Judaism and Islam are closer in theology than Christianity is to either of them. In Judaism and Islam they believe in One God who is able to forgive sins alone. In Christianity God is Three (the Trinity) and God had to come down in the form of a man to die so he could forgive sins. In that sense no Christianity and Islam don't worship the same god.
Judaism and Islam reject all forms of polytheism including that of God in there persons. They are purely monotheistic.
Matther 22: 37 Jesus replied: “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind. 38 This is the first and greatest commandment. 39 And the second is like it: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself. 40 All the Law and the Prophets hang on these two commandments.”
Originally posted by Sahabi
Jesus/Son and Holy Ghost are only worshipped by Christians.
Originally posted by freedish
reply to post by thewholepicture
Jews and Christians worship the same God. Although Jews don't seem to believe that Jesus was God.
Muslims are way off base. I truly think that's a doctrine of devils.
Here's the problem with Judaism.
You can never be good enough for God. You can never follow the law well enough and get into Heaven.
Everyone falls short of the glory of God. It's so simple- that's why we NEED a saviour, Jesus!
I'm not too sure about Islam- but unless it teaches that we can't get to Heaven by our own deeds, an that Jesus is the son of God, it is wrong. Sorry if that seems closed minded.
Originally posted by adjensen
Originally posted by Sahabi
Jesus/Son and Holy Ghost are only worshipped by Christians.
Except that, by Christian theology, the Father, Son and Holy Ghost are all God. Three aspects, one essence. Three perspectives, one will. Sort of how the happy me, the quiet me and the sad me are all still me, or how my intellect is me, my wisdom is me and my body is me. Not the same thing, but that's a way of looking at it.
So when a Muslim worships God, they are, indeed, worshiping Jesus, just not knowingly (or willfully, depending on how you look at it.) Not that it really matters -- Christian salvation comes through the acceptance and following of Christ, not through the act of worshiping him.
Originally posted by Snickersman
Originally posted by adjensen
So when a Muslim worships God, they are, indeed, worshiping Jesus, just not knowingly (or willfully, depending on how you look at it.) Not that it really matters -- Christian salvation comes through the acceptance and following of Christ, not through the act of worshiping him.
You couldn't be more incorrect with your statement. Why are you using a Trinity concept for people like Muslims who believe Allah cannot become a human and be divided? It defeats the purpose of the "Oneness of G-d or Allah". The Christian doctrine of Jesus is so different that it's like a new religion.