The following is my opinion as a member participating in this discussion.
Originally posted by Firefly_
So you are saying that christians of not just catholic, but other denominations, have never used fear and ignorance to control people?
No religion that teaches salvation through “faith alone” can be a religion of control.
If you don't understand “salvation by faith”, I recommend that you start studying the Bible more, as its a very difficult concept to miss.
“Justification by faith” means that no matter what I do, as long as I am sincerely sorry, and ask forgiveness, I am forgiven. Luther was the first
to split from Catholicism, and this one one of the main points in his 95 Theses.
Originally Luther had intended to reform Catholicism, as he honestly believed that the Indulgence Peddlers were the ones using “fear” to
“control” and sell forgiveness. He wrote the 95 Theses in the hopes that the pope would see the abuse of men like John Tetzel, and go back to a
“grace based” forgiveness. It ended up that the pope was very much behind what was happening, and was using the money from Indulgences to pay for
the building of his cathedrals.
Originally posted by Firefly_
Come on, its only very recently that women and homosexuals have been accepted as equals, things the bible completely forbid.
That has nothing to do with a religion “controlling” you.
When people say that something is a religion of “control” they mean that its being abused by a government, or religious organization, to make
people act a certain way via threat. For example, the Roman Catholics teaching that if you paid them enough money they would eliminate your relatives
time in Purgatory. That is control...
However, with that said...
Under “salvation through grace” anyone committing any sin can be forgiven as long as they are penitent and ask forgiveness.
So what it's
saying is not “if you do this, you go to hell” (control)... What its actually saying is “try not to do this, but if you do, realize that its not
what God wants you to do, ask him for forgiveness, and try not to do it again” (Grace)...
What you seem to want is a religion that has no rules or morals... There is no religion has no “rules”. If that is what you want, a life without
any rules, your not going to find that on this Earth
As far as women go, I have never seen a woman treated any differently in any church I have ever belonged too. The only difference is that in some
faiths they cannot be clergy, but they hold many other equally high positions within the church.
Originally posted by Firefly_
If you fail to understand how religion is used and abused by the people in control, then I guess you should just give up on this subject. Even now, to
this very day, it still happens.
Please feel free to enlighten me.
Originally posted by Firefly_
God in the bible (and qur'an etc) claims to be the judge, jury and executioner. It is he who condemns, not sin. Sin is made up by religion to control
people.
Sin exists because God exists. Being sinful is falling outside the perfection of God or going against the Will of God. Grace is a way that we can
still be in the presence of God while having been sinful creatures in the past.
Originally posted by Firefly_
You cannot transgress against something that is imaginary. If there is some sort of higher power, and I do not doubt there is something bigger going
on than we are aware of, you can bet your ass its not written down in some old books.
That is an opinion that the vast majority of the people on the planet disagree with you on.
I am not even going to bother with the rest as you seem to be a confirmed non-believer, who is not here to have a discussion in line with the OP. My
question then is; why come into a thread that is about the topic of religion, and is being discusses by people who obviously chose to believe, just to
let us know that you don't? Don't you think that people can figure out on their own that they can chose to not believe if they so decide?
As an ATS Staff Member, I will not moderate in threads such as this where I have participated as a member.