It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Bedlam
Originally posted by krossfyter
justification is .00001% of the universe. that's a lot. the rest is unjustified or never going to be justified.
I think we should strive to understand what we can understand. By learning about things, what they do, why they do it and how they interrelate to other things.
I don't believe that contemplating Master Hakuin is a way to do that, although it might be a nice way to pass the time.
Originally posted by InfiniteConsciousness
Bedlam shows a great vigor in debunking something so innocuous. Is it the topic at hand which causes your distress or is it just the act of "debunking" that gets you going? Because you've put a lot of energy into this thread. I'd like to understand why.
Does it bother you that people might grow their hair long and see for themselves?
Does it bother you when you see others with long hair?
Do you have a disdain for Native American spirituality and/or philosophy? What about samurai? They also wore their hair long and I'm sure they had their reasons. Shouldn't we track down their reasons and debunk those, too?
Because, lets face it, long hair is a real problem that needs to be seriously addressed and thank God you're here to do it. Good show, ol' chap. I can't wait for your next installment of, "Science says your full of it."
Originally posted by VeritasAequitas
reply to post by Bedlam
Oh no, I don't believe every person who I disagree with as being a 'shill'. In fact, I use that term to include anyone who just really attempts to derail a thread, even though they have no personal experience in the matter. Have you ever grown your hair to your waist? Intuition can't be put under a microscope and scrutinized, it exists for the people who experience it. The people who haven't are the ones who remain skeptical, although they have no real experience to draw knowledge from.
Originally posted by krossfyter
reply to post by Bedlam
well to me im curious as to why our current society is so gun ho and kind of fascist on the whole short hair, cut your hair to fit into a system thing. thats rather curious to me. i wonder if it at all has to do with society wanting its players to be less individual and more drone, robot like for our western industrialization?
cut your hair for a job, cut your hair in the military, those with long hair are seen as abnormal or not right.
but our current society for whatever reason has programmed us to believe that growing hair is something abnormal or not right or out of step? it ridicules it even. sure you play things off and say its purely functional. that the military personal need to have clean heads for functional reasons etc. etc. but i say thats not all there is to it. there is symbolism to these things. something is up.
is it like how society has a stigma against natural hallucinogens and a proclivity for shoving caffeine down our throat? hallucinogens make you more aware and help you question whats behind the veil where as caffeine aids western industrialization, helps turn the systems wheels etc.
im not so against, or take a negative tone with those who believe (faith based i guess) that hair does have psychic or tracking abilities, to the point i make fun of them or question their credibility in a very proud and non humble manner...you know they treat things that we dont know much about with fear and hate. i thing that is wrong. thats what i dont like.
those same people thought the world was flat.
Originally posted by Bedlam
You see that a lot? In the sixties it was a big deal but I don't see all that many people caring these days, unless it's in a field where you have to have a good facial seal on a mask, like cops, firefighters, paramedics, that sort of thing. There are practical aspects where long hair and beards get in the way, and those would be three jobs in that category.
Originally posted by Bedlam
Well, I'm not just playing it off, it's true. You can't get a good seal on a mask with a beard. You can have a mustache to an extent. You really don't want long hair in the field, either, for sanitary reasons. I don't like lice, and it's a lot easier to keep a buzzcut clean with a little bit of wash water than hair down your back. But I see people with long hair, short hair, shaved, pretty much everything between in civilian life. There doesn't seem to be a societal bugaboo at present from my pov, although that certainly hasn't always been true. Even tats and piercings are becoming pretty much run of the mill as long as you don't look like tiger man.
Originally posted by Bedlam
Maybe it's just because I don't ever grow mine out past my ears that I don't notice it. I have seen people freak out when I'm full ZZ Top, the first time someone locked their car door when I rolled up alongside them I didn't know whether to be insulted or tickled.
Originally posted by Bedlam
Guess I'll never know on that one. The only time I got something that made me hallucinate it was pretty bad. Very odd, but bad. Luckily it was something the doc gave me, they had something to calm it down. If that's what's behind the veil, leave it down for me.
Originally posted by Bedlam
Not to be seen as attacking the metaphor, the same approach you don't seem to care for proved the world was round, and Erastosthenes got a pretty close guess as to the size about 250BCE. It was the Mesopotamians and Persians that thought it was flat. The Greeks pretty much never did.
Originally posted by Bedlam
I'm pretty much your antithesis - I'm full on empiricist. If there's no obvious mechanism for such a thing to be true, or even a reality-based conjecture as to how it could be true, at least some observational data demonstrating it's true nonetheless gathered in a way to preclude or at least reduce subjective input and intentional falsification, that's replicable whenever or whoever does the data gathering, then it's tough for me to accept. Two different world views, I suppose.
Originally posted by Bedlam
Originally posted by InfiniteConsciousness
Bedlam shows a great vigor in debunking something so innocuous. Is it the topic at hand which causes your distress or is it just the act of "debunking" that gets you going? Because you've put a lot of energy into this thread. I'd like to understand why.
It intrigues me in several ways. There's a couple of different response types going on - you've got the incredibly credulous for whom the idea that hair is actually some sort of nerve cell that's connected into your telepathy centers is a valid possibility. You've got a few who will go so far down that line that they'll defend the fact that copper and hair both have tensile strength which somehow makes them both radio antennas. And you've got a bunch that read that "indian tracker" crap and snap it up at face value. For those guys, you could at least have a bit of hope that if you provide a bit of guidance on how to read hoax chain emails such as that one, you could assist them not to be as easily suckered. There are so very many problems with that thing.
Does it bother you that people might grow their hair long and see for themselves?
No, in fact I invite you guys to devise some sort of scientifically valid test that has sufficient sample size, is blinded and actually tests for the thing you're looking for with a minimum of confounders. Or to find some valid study that did. You guys seem to be about the purely subjective though, so good luck there. Vague feelings are the worst when you "see for yourself", it's a sort of placebo effect meets confirmation bias thing. If you grew long hair and could fart lightning or make your eyes light up bright green it might be a bit less anecdotal, but still you'd have a problem that short hair/no lightning is just some sort of conversion reaction instead of losing an ability. Testing for mental states is very difficult.
Does it bother you when you see others with long hair?
Nope. Does it bother you when you see others with buzzcuts?
Do you have a disdain for Native American spirituality and/or philosophy? What about samurai? They also wore their hair long and I'm sure they had their reasons. Shouldn't we track down their reasons and debunk those, too?
If they liked the way it looked, great! If they think it gives them telepathic powers and claim it on an ATS thread, bring 'em on, let's see.
Because, lets face it, long hair is a real problem that needs to be seriously addressed and thank God you're here to do it. Good show, ol' chap. I can't wait for your next installment of, "Science says your full of it."
And yet, are you guys not doing the same, only claiming 'metaphysics and very loose pseudoscience says it works because I feel all intuitive'? With "Sally [last name redacted for confidentiality] says she read a study from the War Department done 20 years after it was dissolved" sauce?
Dismissing the indian tracker thing as the dreck it is, so far all the arguments here for seem to be that you have some vague subjective feeling about it, reinforced by the belief that other cultures whom you admire had long hair. But other similar cultures did not. Is it that if you have long hair you're looking for some external validation that it also confers psychic powers or extra individuality or whatnot in addition? Any "indian tracker"/long hair=psychic believers on the thread with short hair?
Originally posted by krossfyter
its not for everyone. not sure what you took. not every trip is good. but there is a reason the govt. wants it supressed and its not to protect you.
Originally posted by InfiniteConsciousness
Thank you for the well thought out response. Now I've got a few more questions for you. Do you believe in the placebo effect? If so, why and how do you believe it works?
What do you believe consciousness is and how it interfaces with our brain and the external / internal "reality"?
Have you ever honestly investigated your own psychic ability?
If you think indian trackers are a hoax or do not have better ability, welp, I've got this mighty fine bridge I want you to consider buying. Since you don't really know how they have better ability and can only offer flimsy speculation, you shouldn't be so quick to dismiss it.
I saw a comment of yours earlier in the thread about "antennae don't vibrate". Really? How do you know this? Because, from what I understand, everything in the Universe vibrates at different frequencies. How do you know that you cannot become in tune with these different vibrational frequencies and use that as an extra sense?
The military has known about ESP ability for decades.
Originally posted by InfiniteConsciousness
Great job shucking and jiving mr. physicist, Bedlam....
You managed to avoid every single question I asked with a bunch of BS. Why?
You gave a ridiculously inadequate answer to my first question with a sentence I can barely understand how it addressed the question at all.
Why do you ask me to define "universe" and give three examples as an "answer" to my question about consciousness?
I never said Native Americans were military trackers. I simply made the point that they are incredible trackers. At least they used to be until genocide was committed against them and were corralled into tiny parcels of land, given liquor for their pain and casinos. I digress.