posted on Sep, 29 2004 @ 12:10 PM
Debate Briefing Book
�for�
SENATOR KERRY
Debate 1: Foreign Policy
(As Prepared By Bush-Cheney �04)
not a vote about a message. It is
a vote about war.�
You are saying the removal of
Saddam Hussein has left America
�less secure.� Unfortunately, you
also told Howard Dean, �Those who
doubted whether Iraq or the world
would be better off without Saddam
Hussein, and those who believe we
are not safer with his capture,
don't have the judgment to be
president or the credibility to
be elected president.�
You are saying the U.S. is
spending too much money on Iraq,
but in August 2003, you said we
need to increase funding for Iraq
�by whatever number of billions of
dollars it takes to win.�
You refused to take a position on
whether or not the war you voted
for was �illegal.�
You have said knowing everything
you know now, you still would have
voted for the war but knowing
everything we know now the war was
a mistake.
Your Attacks
Pretend like no position you have
ever taken matters. Political
opportunity, pessimism and the
implication of inevitable defeat
is the key here. Nobody knows
what you really believe anyway.
2
Issue:Iraq
Your Current Position
� The removal of Saddam Hussein
has left America less secure.
You are currently against the
war and wouldn't have gone to
war, but you used to be for the
war before you were against the
war before you were for the war.
Your Record
You voted for �the wrong war, in
the wrong place, at the wrong
time.� Now you say the war you
voted for made us �less safe.�
You said voting against the
funding for the war would be
�irresponsible.� That was before
you voted against the funds.
You said �it would be na�ve to the
point of grave danger� not to
confront Saddam Hussein.
During the Democrat primaries,
you said, �I think it was the
right decision to disarm Saddam
Hussein, and when the President
made the decision, I supported
him, and I support the fact that
we did disarm him.� That was
before the surge of Howard Dean
led you to declare yourself an
�anti-war� candidate.
You are saying your vote for the
war was a vote to �authorize� war
so America could send a united
message to Saddam. But don't
forget in 1991 you said, �This is
1
longer than it took for the first
Gulf War that you now praise but
voted against. (It started two
days after the vote.)
You once asked, �Where�s the
backbone of Russia, where�s the
backbone of France� to confront
Iraq. Now you are claiming the
President just had to wait a
little longer, and they would
have helped.
You once claimed you �heard from�
foreign leaders who supported
your election, and said you can
meet foreign leaders in any New
York City restaurant.
During your convention you
implied that the use of force is
only required AFTER America is
attacked. So your current
position on preemption is
�against.�
Your Attack
Imply you can get nations like
France and Germany to help in
Iraq, even though France and
Germany have said they won't help.
Say you didn't mean to attack
Prime Minister Allawi, but
Carville and Begala have been
lecturing you about rapid
response.
4
Issue: Diplomacy
Your Current Position
� President Bush is a
unilateralist (don't count the
30 nations in Iraq), and you are
a multilateralist, except when
you insult our allies (then you
are an opportunist).
Your Record
You said Iraqi Prime Minister
Allawi doesn't know what's
happening in his own country, and
made a political attack on him
moments after he thanked the
American people for the
liberation of his country.
You said we need more allies, but
you have called our allies
�coerced,� �bribed,�
�fraudulent,� �window dressing�
and �barely willing to do anything
at all.� This probably won't help
you recruit more allies, but you
don't think that's going to
happen anyway.
You have characterized our troops
in Iraq as �occupiers.� Try not
to use that word. Your Democratic
colleague Senator Miller will
come down on you and so will most
Americans.
You said the President �rushed to
war,� and you cited the first Gulf
War as a model of diplomacy. Of
course, six months separated the
vote for the war and the beginning
of the war. That is six months
3
Issue: Troop Realignment
Your Current Position
� Troop realignment is bad - you
have said troop realignment
�does not strengthen our hand
in the war on terror.�
Your Record
Troop realignment is good -
specifically, you wanted to shift
troops �in the Korean peninsula
perhaps, in Europe perhaps.�
Your Attack
This didn't go so well last time,
so you might want to stay away
from it. But remember if they
ask, you said �perhaps� so it
doesn't count!
6
Issue: Intelligence
Your Current Position
� The Administration is moving
too slowly on intelligence
reform.
Your Record
In 1994, you proposed $6 billion
in across the board cuts to
intelligence after the first
World Trade Center bombing.
These cuts didn't receive much
support. You were actually the
only Senator from Massachusetts
to vote for them.
Sen. Inouye (D-HI) said your bill
�would severely hamper�
intelligence efforts.
You missed 76 percent of public
Senate Intelligence Committee
hearings and we are trying to keep
the private attendance record
under wraps.
Edwards also missed 69 percent of
his public Senate Intelligence
Committee hearings.
Unfortunately, that is his main
national security experience.
In 1995, you voted to cut $80
million in FBI funding for
counterterrorism.
Your Attack
Say the President is going too
slowly. (Except for the 36 of the
41 9/11 Commission proposals that
he is implementing.)
5
Issue: North Korea
Your Current Position
� We need to negotiate directly
with the North Koreans.
Your Record
You seek a return to the failed
Clinton era policies of signing
deals with the North Korean
government that they have no
intention to honor. You have
called the multilateral
negotiations �basically a cover,�
arguing that they aren't
legitimate.
The state-run media of North Korea
has reported: �Senator Kerry, who
is seeking the presidential
candidacy of the Democratic
Party, sharply criticised
President Bush, saying it was an
ill-considered act to deny direct
dialogue with North Korea.�
You have said the President
�talks the game but doesn't
deliver,� but it isn't clear your
concessions on the talks would
deliver anything to anyone but
the North Koreans.
Your Attack
The President should negotiate
directly with the North Koreans,
even though that strategy has
already failed.
8
Issue: Afghanistan
Your Current Position
� Afghanistan is where the War on
Terror really belongs.
Your Record
You previously said the War on
Terror �doesn�t end with
Afghanistan,� and we needed to
move on to address other threats
�for instance, Saddam Hussein.�
Now you believe Iraq is a
distraction from Afghanistan.
You voted against the $87 billion
that included funds for
ammunition and body armor for
troops in Afghanistan.
Your Attack
Afghanistan is being neglected,
even though you voted against
funds for our troops there.
7
Issue: Cuba
Your Current Position
� You said you voted for the
Helms-Burton Act, which cracked
down on companies dealing with
Cuba. (Peter Wallsten, �Kerry�s
Cuba Stances Open To Attack,�
The Miami Herald, 3/14/04)
Your Record
You voted against the Helms-
Burton Act, but now you say you
actually voted for it. Try not to
mess that up again.
Your latest position is that you
would not lift the embargo
against Cuba, but in 2000 you said
Florida politics were the only
reason the embargo was still in
place and that a reevaluation is
�way overdue.� Unfortunately,
last year you explained that
comment by saying you were �being
honest.� That does raise the
uncomfortable question of what
you are being now.
You voted to ease sanctions
against Cuba and said you were
�skeptical� of the embargo. That
was when you were �being honest.�
You supported a commission to
study if Cuba was still a threat.
Again: �being honest.�
Your Attack
Disregard your own record and
statements and attack.
10
Issue: Israel
Your Current Position
� You are foragainst the Israeli
security fence. It is both a
�barrier to peace� and a
�legitimate act of self
defense.�
Your Record
The Israeli security fence is a
�barrier to peace� when you are
talking to Arab audiences
(Remarks Before Arab American
Institute National Leadership
Conference, Dearborn, MI,
10/17/03) and a �legitimate act of
self defense� when you are talking
to Jewish audiences (Janine
Zacharia, �Kerry Defends Security
Fence,� The Jerusalem Post,
2/25/04).
You wrote in your book, The New
War, that Yasser Arafat is a
�statesman� and a �role model.�
This is the same book in which
you warned that the Japanese
Yakuza would be a major threat
to our future.
Your Attack
The President is not exhibiting
leadership on this issue. (Ignore
your own split positions, and
don't ever get your positions
mixed up with the wrong audience.
The consequences could be
disastrous.)
9
Homeland Security
Your Current Position
� You say the War on Terror is
�far more of a law enforcement
and intelligence operation than
it is a day-to-day huge
military operation.�
Your Record
You delayed the creation of the
Department of Homeland Security
by 112 days because you wanted
national security workers to be
unionized.
You skipped last year's vote for
the $29.3 billion Homeland
Security appropriation.
Your Attack
The President delayed and underfunded
the Homeland Security
Department.
(The truth is the President has
tripled funding for homeland
security since 2001, but a little
extra stretch of the truth won't
hurt your damaged credibility any
further.
12
Issue: The Patriot Act
Your Current Position
� The Patriot Act is bad and you
plan on �replacing the Patriot
Act with a new law.�
Your Record
You voted for the Patriot Act, and
said on the Senate floor that you
were �pleased� with the Patriot
Act.
You said the wiretap provision
�modernizes our ability to fight
crime.� (That was before you
wanted to weaken the wiretap
provisions.)
During the primaries, you
discovered Democrats didn't like
the Patriot Act. That's when you
changed your position to be for
�replacing� the Patriot Act.
After discovering other people
didn't like the Patriot Act, you
attacked it, calling it a �knock
in the night� and saying it didn't
protect �our liberties.�
Your Attack
Don't mention the Patriot Act
gives law enforcement the same
tools to use against terrorists
that they already use against
drug dealers.
11
Debate Briefing Book
�for�
SENATOR KERRY
Debate 1: Foreign Policy
(As Prepared By Bush-Cheney �04)
Paid for by Bush-Cheney �04, Inc.