It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Merigold
When I was 17 my best friends name was Cindy. Cindy confided in me that she was a lesbian. I promised not to tell anyone, but I did. Cindy became estranged form her very religious family and eventually moved out of town. I never heard from her again. I lied, I told her I hadn't told anyone.
I feel guilty about this to this day.
Originally posted by operation mindcrime
Originally posted by Merigold
When I was 17 my best friends name was Cindy. Cindy confided in me that she was a lesbian. I promised not to tell anyone, but I did. Cindy became estranged form her very religious family and eventually moved out of town. I never heard from her again. I lied, I told her I hadn't told anyone.
I feel guilty about this to this day.
But....you did tell the truth about Cindy.
Peace
The truth came out, but it didn't come from the horses mouth. Sometimes people prefer to live with secrets, as it holds the key to their well-being. Everyone responds differently to this. It's safe to say, this was one of the girl's bigger skeletons in the closet, given how she responded to it all.
Sometimes, the benefit may not be for ourselves, but for others, but that doesn't make it right.
Originally posted by operation mindcrime
reply to post by BeyondPerception
The truth came out, but it didn't come from the horses mouth. Sometimes people prefer to live with secrets, as it holds the key to their well-being. Everyone responds differently to this. It's safe to say, this was one of the girl's bigger skeletons in the closet, given how she responded to it all.
That makes absolutly no sense. You said:"
Sometimes, the benefit may not be for ourselves, but for others, but that doesn't make it right.
Merigold's secret was a secret, was it not?
I'm confused....
Peace
Originally posted by BeyondPerception
The sentence in context: The benefit of telling a lie
E.g. You witness someone stealing something, and you lie to cover it all up to save them from penalty. They benefit, not you. And now, you both get stuck with a lie to deal with.
Also...
I'm not advocating that we go exposing other people's dirty laundry, but our own.
Telling a secret you've been intrusted with only creates a new lie. So, nothing is really accomplished.
Originally posted by operation mindcrime
Originally posted by BeyondPerception
The sentence in context: The benefit of telling a lie
E.g. You witness someone stealing something, and you lie to cover it all up to save them from penalty. They benefit, not you. And now, you both get stuck with a lie to deal with.
Also...
I'm not advocating that we go exposing other people's dirty laundry, but our own.
Telling a secret you've been intrusted with only creates a new lie. So, nothing is really accomplished.
Different scenario, say you are hiding fugitives in your basement from some dicatorial regime that you don't agree with. They knock on your door and ask if you are harboring any fugitives......lie or tell the truth?
Peace