Why? (Why doesn't Nibiru/Planet X have it's own forum?)

If 2012 Elections have their own forum, and Japan, and 9/11, and 2012, then why doesn't Nibiru/Planet X have it's own?

I personally come here to see new threads on this subject but I find it difficult to locate them sometimes cause they are spread out througout many different forums. I think it deserves its own forum if not for the simple fact that its one of the hottest subjects for the past couple years, then for the fact its been a topic of discussion since the early 1980s...

Also, I wouldn't mind if Elenin threads became discussed in said Nibiru/Planet X forum.

These subjects don't fit in the 2012 forum because 2012 is a fallacy. It also doesn't belong in the General Conspiracies forum either simple because no one is conspiring about it. It shouldn't be in the Grey Area, cause it's far from being a grey area. And finally, it shouldn't just be thrown into the Skunk Works forum cause theres no where else logically to put it, it's a highly talked about subject, and shouldn't be just thrown in with other nonsense.

It deserves it's own forum.

Agreed.

It's high time for this and it will only become more of an issue in the next couple of months-year.

Definitely needs it's own forum.


PS.

Cool Title, by the way...

reply to post by BrnBdry


To the great unwashed, Nibiru = 2012 = HOAX forum in 2013.

Elenin threads should go into space exploration unless it's some stupid thread about Elenin being an ELE or similar, if this is the case, see above.

Because Elenin forums are junk forums. But I suppose a separate forum for that junk would be nice.

The forum should be called: Fear-Mongering and other workings of Trolls.

Good suggestion. Even the "anti's" are for it. Such a forum could take-in a wide array of topics having to do with inter-stellar bodies along with comets and asteroids. ELE and certain doomsday events would fit along with return of the gods and "ancient ones," angels, etc. Such a forum with its own rules would eliminate a lot of trolling and perhaps put seeming unrelated topics side-by-side to perhaps discover a connection.

Sitchin suggested ancient civilizations knew about this and nearly all civilizations to this day have their religions and mythologies that suggest a connection, it is plausible. Seems more productive such topics are not splintered everywhere and bothering those who wish to dismiss and disregard them.

How about just calling it the E.L.E.(Extinction Level Event) Forum? That covers both and does not require the move of an entire Forum to the Hoax bin IF they don't effect the Earth and we are still here. This also clears up the other forums so those that are sick and tired of seeing them can ignore them easier. It sux to open your "myATS" page and there are all kinds of things you are not interested in, in your favorites column.

Originally posted by IPILYA
How about just calling it the E.L.E.(Extinction Level Event) Forum? That covers both and does not require the move of an entire Forum to the Hoax bin IF they don't effect the Earth and we are still here. This also clears up the other forums so those that are sick and tired of seeing them can ignore them easier. It sux to open your "myATS" page and there are all kinds of things you are not interested in, in your favorites column.

edit on 12-7-2011 by IPILYA because: (no reason given)

Although i am not an ELE type thread starter but i do enjoy reading the threads and having a forum to the specific content would be extremely helpful and interesting and perhaps or should i say it would put a stop or lower the amount of double and triple amount of posts.

Originally posted by BrnBdry
why doesn't Nibiru/Planet X have it's own?

Agreed, something along the lines of "Sitchin's Follies" or maybe "Zecharia's Delusions"

Also, I wouldn't mind if Elenin threads became discussed in said Nibiru/Planet X forum.

That would be doing a known real world scientifically viable situation a disservice IMO. Unless of course people insist in dragging Zecharia into the discussion then reference the above mentioned suggestions.

These subjects don't fit in the 2012 forum because 2012 is a fallacy

How is it a fallacy? The year will come and go. The Ancient Calender will end it's cycle.

it's a highly talked about subject, and shouldn't be just thrown in with other nonsense

Emphases mine

Originally posted by BrnBdry
If 2012 Elections have their own forum, and Japan, and 9/11, and 2012, then why doesn't Nibiru/Planet X have it's own?

Well since there already IS a 2012 events forum, making another one would be silly. Since Nibiru and crashing comets all claim to be about 2012 why would you put it anywhere else?



Now since Sitchin is the ONLY source of Nibiru in the first place... you all might want to actually read what he said...

“Nibiru settled into a clockwise orbit (equal to 3,600 orbits of Earth around the Sun). Nibiru stabilized into a clockwise orbit, equal to 3,600 orbits of Earth around the Sun until 10, 900 B.C.E., when Nibiru arrived earlier, due to increasing drift from Solaris of Uranus. Uranus' gravity sped Nibiru's orbit. As a result of this close encounter between Nibiru and Uranus, one of Nibiru's moons, Miranda, was captured by and became a moon of Uranus as Nibiru and Uranus pulled at each other. From 10,000B.C.E. on, Nibiru's revolution sped to 3.450 Earth years; which makes Nibiru's next return 2900A.D. rather than 2012 as predicated on the earlier 3600- year orbit”

Sitchin, Z., 2007, The End of Days, pages 315 - 317


2900 AD not 2012

In Sitchin's own words... that is 892 years away...

Since ELENIN is a relatively minor comet, I wouldn't be to concerned. Beside Nassim Harramein already told us Comet Neat in 2003 was Nibiru and its already come and gone

Video Proof That Nibiru Has Come and Gone




So I propose that ATS plan a big party in Las Vegas for Dec 31st, 2012 and then we can ask all the doom sayers what happened as we ring in 2013

Originally posted by zorgon

Originally posted by BrnBdry
If 2012 Elections have their own forum, and Japan, and 9/11, and 2012, then why doesn't Nibiru/Planet X have it's own?

Well since there already IS a 2012 events forum, making another one would be silly. Since Nibiru and crashing comets all claim to be about 2012 why would you put it anywhere else?

That's not everyones view. So it doesn't belong in there.

Originally posted by BrnBdry
I personally come here to see new threads on this subject but I find it difficult to locate them sometimes cause they are spread out througout many different forums.

Step one :click on "search"
Step two: type in the single word "Nibiru"

Voila!!!! all the Nibiru threads in a neat list

There is a Niburu forum, it's just named 2012.

Niburu is primarily associated with the events of 2012 and therefore fits the criteria of the forum quite well.

Just my thoughts.

~Keeper

It has a forum. It's called Skunk Works. As there is no evidence to support the existence of Nibiru/Planet X it is a highly speculative topic.

reply to post by Xcalibur254


That is your opinion and you are entitled to it, as much as those, who believe in plant X Niribu. They have as much right to discuss the issues. If you do not like the thread posted on the subject then, simple answer. Do not read them.

Anyhoo, Since it regards to events running up to 2012, then, no it does not need a separate forum.

Originally posted by Elsek
Because Elenin forums are junk forums. But I suppose a separate forum for that junk would be nice.

The forum should be called: Fear-Mongering and other workings of Trolls.

Everyone is entitled to believing whatever they want to believe. If enough people are posting topics about Nibiru/Planet X/Elenin(as a ELE), or whatever, it deserves its own forum. For goodness sakes, compare nibiru threads to Japan threads and you will see Nibiru wins. This isn't "repeat MSM", it is ATS.

Originally posted by tothetenthpower
There is a Niburu forum, it's just named 2012.

Niburu is primarily associated with the events of 2012 and therefore fits the criteria of the forum quite well.

Just my thoughts.

~Keeper

I had never associated Nibiru/PlanetX with 2012 except to think there could be some overlap. Seems like complete separate topics outside those few instances. Not sure for when it was predicted to return unless Abraham's time was considered the last appearance then possible 2012 coincides. I have other 2012 factors to consider that could come into play entirely unrelated to Planet-X but really don't put much stock in either.

My argument would be in favor of a separate forum which could well appease the "anti's" that don't wish to have their topics cluttered with it. I don't follow the topic and it may be because it is splintered everywhere. I do find it interesting and have reasons to consider it plausible. At least open-minded about it.

Having too many forums can create and become ghost towns but it really does not raise the rent any to have extras. It really is an area of interest in and of itself. I would ask ATS to at least give it a try. If it doesn't attract sufficient interest then can close or merge it elsewhere.