Could Osama be alive? Seriously?

Is it possible that OBL was captured alive, and is being held and being questioned?

It's just a thought - Capture him alive, tell everyone he is dead, leak a fake photo which shows him injured to the point of death, meanwhile sweat him for info?

Could it happen?

How would they capture him, he's been dead for years.

I could happen and might have.

My only problem with a capture, instead of a kill of this man, would be a hostage situation for his release by his affiliates. So it would be beneficial to stage it this way.
But I still think something stinks about this whole incident!

reply to post by Onet Wosix


It's pretty obvious that Hitler was alive years after his "death". So it isn't unreasonable to think that Osama's death in 2001, 2007 and now in 2011 wasn't manipulated by the media. Maybe O?ama gave his own kill order?

One thing is for certain. O?ama appears to be a CIA fabrication. That's the rabbit hole you want to investigate to see if he's still breathing.

reply to post by Onet Wosix


Who knows.. This whole thing will take up a lot of ATS server space before it's over.

Originally posted by Tephra
How would they capture him, he's been dead for years.

edit on 3-5-2011 by Tephra because: (no reason given)

Only they know what really is going on in the "inside."

Originally posted by Tephra
How would they capture him, he's been dead for years.

edit on 3-5-2011 by Tephra because: (no reason given)

*sigh* STAY on topic....

We all know the general consenus around here, but that's not what he asked.



OP, yes I believe that may be the case. He's worth more alive then dead.

Yes, it is possible. It would only be slightly more difficult than a standard raid to pull off. And if things get sideways, you end up with a body instead of a prisoner. As a matter of fact, I'm convinced by the way this has played out that that is exactly what happened.

Could it be that they already captured him years ago....got all the information from him they wanted....and then killed him on May 1, 2011.

Originally posted by caladonea
Could it be that they already captured him years ago....got all the information from him they wanted....and then killed him on May 1, 2011.

I think that a raid into Pakistan is far too much risk if that was the case. It would be far easier (and much less chance of compromise) to say that we got him in a cave or in transit in Afghanistan.

Originally posted by AnteBellum
I could happen and might have.

I know that's a typo...but that's damn funny.

Very existential of you.

Everything the white house does is done to achive more than one objective ...
The US has always been held hostage by Pakistan and is forced to work with it becuause they have nukes .. things have to be done with care although It's well known that Pakistan's ISI is a state sponsorer of terrorism ...

Making it look like they got OBL inside Pakistan leaves the door open to blame Pakistan and take action against it's terrorist spy agency .. the ISI ... it's all about laying the ground work ...
Think about it .. there is no way the ISI would not have known that OBL was living lavishly 40km from Islamabad ...

If you capture a high ranking terrorist .. why would you be so quick to secretly bury him and scatter the ashes .. or whatever they did to get rid of the evidence .. which ofcourse did not exist ...

All this ofcourse is apart from the fact that OBL, the Bushes, and the CIA and the OBL family is Saudi have always been buddy buddy ... OBL probably is under CIA security somewhere as he has always been living it up .. paid heavily for use of his name in sustaining the so called 'war on terror' ...

I really laughed at the people who were celebrating .. shouting USA USA USA ... what a bunch of morons ... they have no idea their ignorance is fueling these illegal wars ...

There are several threads regarding OBL and his death.

Please add you theories or comments to one of those.

Closed.

~Keeper
ATS Moderator