Originally posted by Gazrok
Communes have attempted this for quite some time. However, inevitably, you will usually want goods not produced by the commune (i.e. tribe), so you'll
need to work out some way of obtaining them from these outside vendors.
Samta and I agree that Arya's Idea of selling lashed together furniture is great.
there could be some scarce resources we decide to attain.
we can help estimate the value of the item with price-calculation.
so really money can be used with tribalism.
though we could rely on tribe for most food and products.
There are also many other forms of attainment.
Biological-cells for instance send out messengers, which find the resource that they desire, and then return it to the cell.
just as traditionally in tribes people can find various items in an environment and make what is wished with available tools.
i guess there is no vs, it's all co-operation.
it's really us.
even fiat could be used, though it's the amount of fiat
would have to be recalculated regularly,
due to it's inherit inflation.
Barter may be the solution, but how many chickens equal a flat screen TV?
price-calculation formula
mass^chakra = price
a chicken weight about 1.5kg
animal so chakra >= 2.5,
relatively primitve animal so lets say chakra 2.7
chickenMass^chickenChakra
1.5^2.7
37inch flat-screen tv 15kg
for choosing-expression so chakra 3.5
tvMass^tvChakra
15^35
so lets put that together algebraically
tvMass^tvChakra = (chickenMass*amount)^chickenChakra
get root of chickenChakra on both sides
root(tvMass^tvChakra,chickenChakra) = chickenMass*amount
divide both sides by chickenMass to isolate amount
root(tvMass^tvChakra,chickenChakra)/chickenMass = amount
and inputting the formula values
root(15^3.5, 2.7) / 1.5 = approx. 22.308557
so such a tv is worth about 22 chickens, and 1 chick.
root(15^3.5, 2.7) = approx. 33.462836
or about 33.5 kg of chicken-level animal-mass.
with dogs weighing about 13kg at chakra 2.9
root(15^3.5, 2.9) = approx. 26.267605 kg
root(15^3.5, 2.9) / 13 = approx. 2.020585 dogs
so about 2 medium sized dogs.
But there are challenges.
sure, algebra is a skill to learn,
and certainly beneficial to have a calculator.
To make it easier for pattern-matching-brains.
We could make conversion tables,
converting products to some standard product,
like dried food.
Also could have computers calculate prices,
including things like abundance on the market.
though the market itself could provide those values.
the buyer can also set the utility,
so if it's less than 1, they are willing to buy cheap,
if it's greater than 1, they are willing to pay more.
for instance perhaps they could have a high utility for prefered items,
wheras they could have a low utility for items they have in surplus.
edit on 1/11/10 by lowki because: added dog equivalence