It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
Originally posted by Scramjet76
reply to post by something wicked
b) that they are more superior?
Yes they are superior. We aren't talking about the difference between "Bill Gates" and your average working stiff. Bill Gates eats, drinks, breathes, and will someday die. Bill Gates makes software and operating systems for personal computers made possible by the invention of the transistor. While this is very interesting and all, it still effectively makes Gates a human, and just another ant compared to a truly old/advanced civilization.
These beings are far beyond that. Far far beyond that. Why would they care of Bill Gates uses primitive software for primitive machines and has billions of dollars? Let me ask you some questions:
Would you think "Bill Gates" (or any human from a Type 0 civilization) was exceptional if you had already met other Type 2 civilizations and even possibly Type 3 civilization(s)? Would you think humans are amazing if you didn't need to breathe, eat, or drink in the way that sustains us? Would you think of Bill Gates (or any person) as exceptional if you had watched them die generation after generation while you still live? Would you find rockets and satellites to be that amazing if your civilization had left their home planet thousands or even millions of years ago in huge star ships? If you were an indestructible alien that did not require a home planet to survive, would you really find earthlings who fear, hurt, and kill eachother that exceptional? Would you think billions of dollars is wonderful if your civilization had no use for money or currency?
While I'm agnostic, I do think the God making men in his own image thing is an allegory, more around intellect and intelligence than physical form, otherwise we would all literally look the same - wouldn't we?
Let me get this right.. You believe that your intelligence is nearly on par with the intelligence that may be responsible for the creation of our univese? Is this an early april fool's joke? Because I'm not laughing.
Wow.edit on 29-10-2010 by Scramjet76 because: spl
Originally posted by Scramjet76
reply to post by something wicked
b) that they are more superior?
Yes they are superior. We aren't talking about the difference between "Bill Gates" and your average working stiff. Bill Gates eats, drinks, breathes, and will someday die. Bill Gates makes software and operating systems for personal computers made possible by the invention of the transistor. While this is very interesting and all, it still effectively makes Gates a human, and just another ant compared to a truly old/advanced civilization.
These beings are far beyond that. Far far beyond that. Why would they care of Bill Gates uses primitive software for primitive machines and has billions of dollars? Let me ask you some questions:
Would you think "Bill Gates" (or any human from a Type 0 civilization) was exceptional if you had already met other Type 2 civilizations and even possibly Type 3 civilization(s)? Would you think humans are amazing if you didn't need to breathe, eat, or drink in the way that sustains us? Would you think of Bill Gates (or any person) as exceptional if you had watched them die generation after generation while you still live? Would you find rockets and satellites to be that amazing if your civilization had left their home planet thousands or even millions of years ago in huge star ships? If you were an indestructible alien that did not require a home planet to survive, would you really find earthlings who fear, hurt, and kill eachother that exceptional? Would you think billions of dollars is wonderful if your civilization had no use for money or currency?
While I'm agnostic, I do think the God making men in his own image thing is an allegory, more around intellect and intelligence than physical form, otherwise we would all literally look the same - wouldn't we?
Let me get this right.. You believe that your intelligence is nearly on par with the intelligence that may be responsible for the creation of our univese? Is this an early april fool's joke? Because I'm not laughing.
Wow.edit on 29-10-2010 by Scramjet76 because: spl
Originally posted by PayMeh
reply to post by something wicked
Okay, consider this then. Where I believe religion would falter would be in the fact that IF it became apparent that it was technologically advanced alien life that is the basis of all religion, would it not take the paranormal/omnipotent factor out of it all? If aliens are biological creatures and were to come back, would we still worship them knowing what we know today? If Elohim and YHWH came back today on a spaceship and presented themselves to humans, would you still call them "God?" or would you be more likely to view them as a sort of equal? Somehow I doubt any main stream religion's followers would readily bow down to another biological lifeform regardless of how advanced they are. Sure there still is the possibility of a creator, but it would make Him one who's only function is to create if all our texts are about biological aliens. For people who need religion, this fact means that they know absolutely nothing about the Creator.
Edit to add. I didn't read through the entire thread before I responded back to you. I see my points have already been brought up.edit on 30-10-2010 by PayMeh because: (no reason given)