star wars, star trek, or star gate.

originally posted by: Elentarri
Does anyone else picture Cardassians when they come across references of "Reptilians" on ATS?

No, I've actually thought of the Xindi-Reptilians some reason.

Do I have to choose? Can't it just be "pick one to discard"? Because i don't care much for SW, I can discard that easily.
I can't pick between ST & Stargate, I really can't. Someone even managed to fuse ST & Stargate in a fanfic I've been following all year:
SG-1's Long Trek Home

I am torn between Star Wars and Stargate. Ill go with Stargate as I just finished watching the series a few months back.
Not happy with the movie remake decision. Read the original books with how it was suposed to go before it was made a series and it was ok, but the series was so much better story line wise.
If there was a 2nd movie back in the 90's, it would have been about the goddess Hathor waking up after Ra's death.
Hathor is a human that is hundreds if not thousands of years old due to Ra's sarcophagus, and she goes on a rampage of destruction in revenge of Ra's death.

Read them years and ago and quiet liked it. But did not compare to the Tv series which included aliens not just humans.
Ra was the only alian in the original plotline.

Prefer startrek as it has more substance, and extremely more durable and can last the haul with many spin off series each entertaining in their own right. Starwars climaxed with Empire strikes back and its gonna take more than some galactic Viagra to boot that Franchise again. Mabey what has hurt starwars is the creative control of Lucas, mabey now hes handed it over to someone else it will take it to new places never wondered possible. The short of the new starwars suggests its going to be blended with a lord of the rings type feel which I can see working.

a reply to: president

Neither.

Try STARCRAFT.

Stargate SG-1 and Atlantis all the way. Completely changed how my mind was working at a young age when I started to watch them and showed me a whole world of possibilities. Absolutely amazing. O yeah, and Teyla

Startrek, because space is about the unknown and final frontier and no one does that better than trek. No one can argue because of the depth of startrek movies and series, that it has infinitely more depth than starwars and this ill only become apparent again in the new starwars which I predict will bomb, it wont reignite the franchise because the original movie made in 77 used cutting edge effects of the day, and the movies biggest star was special effects, and they have been replaced by CGI which doesn't have the same feel as original (that lived in universe). The original magic of starwars is gone and cant be brought back. Startrek was always about exploring humanities relationship with whats out there, and how we will experience that and find a place in something where we are far from the highest species on food chain. Startrek wins over starwars anyday. The only good starwars was the first movie, and there it should of ended.

a reply to: president

star trek has the prettier ladies.

I like all three, but if I had to choose it would be star trek. I like the "perfect" Earth society they have built. Voyager is my favorite, then Next Generation. I didn't like Deep Space Nine that much though.