Home Truths You'll Never Read in the Press

Home Truths You'll Never Read in the Press
Who's Really Running Iraq?

PATRICK COCKBURN

August 2, 2008


uruknet.info...

American politicians and journalists have repeatedly made the same mistake in Iraq over the past five years. This is to assume that the US is far more in control of events in the country than has ever truly been the case. This was true after the fall of Saddam Hussein when President Bush and his viceroy in Baghdad Paul Bremer believed that what Iraqis thought and did could safely be ignored. Within months guerrilla war against American forces was raging across central Iraq.

The ability of America to make unilateral decisions in Iraq is diminishing by the month, but the White House was still horrified to hear the Iraqi prime minister Nouri al-Maliki appearing to endorse Barack Obama’s plan for the withdrawal of American combat troops over 16 months. This cut the ground from under the feet of John McCain who has repeatedly declared that 'victory’ is at last within America’s grasp because of the great achievements of 'the Surge’, the American reinforcements sent to Iraq in 2007 to regain control of Baghdad.

The success of 'the Surge’ is becoming almost received wisdom in the US. This is strange since, if the US strategy did win such an important victory, why do America generals need more soldiers, currently 147,000 of them, in Iraq than they did before 'the Surge’ started? But belief in this so-called victory is in keeping with the American tradition of seeing everything that happens in Iraq as being the result of actions by the US alone. The complex political landscape of Iraq is ignored. US commentators have never quite taken on board that there are not one but three wars being fought out in the country since 2003: the first is the war of resistance against the American occupation by insurgents from the Sunni Arab community. The second is the battle between the Sunni and Shia communities as to who should rule the Iraqi state in succession to Saddam Hussein. The third conflict is a proxy war between the US and Iran to decide who should be the predominant foreign power in Iraq. The real, though exaggerated, fall in violence in Iraq over the last year is a consequence of developments in all three of these wars, but they do not necessarily have much to do with 'the Surge’.

uruknet.info...

This is all a blatant lie, the surge has worked...to restore order, BUT it has done nothing in forcing their government to do something on their own. We have trained their soldiers, sure, they have an army now...but that means zero, because there is still no infrastructure, and they still depend on us for their financing...Anyhow your article is highly misleading and mostly uninformed of the situation.