wtc impact - contradicting flightpaths?

G'day all
Found this one today, two pieces of footage from 911, each showing a different version of events.
Is one fake?
Are they Both fake?
Are they both real and I'm an idiot?
The first piece shows the tower exploding apparently without a plane entering the scene (or at least none that I can see), The second piece of footage is on a similar angle and shows an object enter from the right
Please discuss =)




[edit on 13-5-2008 by twisted-timothy]

reply to post by twisted-timothy


Anybody?


My first real thread turns out to be a flop
-think I'll go and eat worms (just kidding, I'm a vegetarian)

If you had watched close would have noticed logos from 2 different
New York TV stations - WNBC (Channel 4) and WPIX (Channel 11)
Video was shot from 2 different angles - Channel 4 foorage is from
helicopter North of WTC complex (WTC 1 - North Tower, bld with antenna)
in foreground. Plane came from south and struck South-East corner
of WTC 2 (South Tower). Its approach was blocked by WTC 1 and smoke
cloud. Many of my co-workers on top floor of our building in New Jersey
watched it slam into WTC 2.
What you are seeing is plane as it punches through building and debris
cloud emerging out other side. Fuel cloud aerosol explodes in massive
fireball.

Second video was shot from what looks like east side of Manhattan,
camera angle shows approach of plane and impact with building

Its simply matter of camera location and direction it was looking at.

Originally posted by thedman

If you had watched close would have noticed logos from 2 different
New York TV stations - WNBC (Channel 4) and WPIX (Channel 11)
Video was shot from 2 different angles - Channel 4 foorage is from
helicopter North of WTC complex (WTC 1 - North Tower, bld with antenna)
in foreground. Plane came from south and struck South-East corner
of WTC 2 (South Tower). Its approach was blocked by WTC 1 and smoke
cloud. Many of my co-workers on top floor of our building in New Jersey
watched it slam into WTC 2.
What you are seeing is plane as it punches through building and debris
cloud emerging out other side. Fuel cloud aerosol explodes in massive
fireball.

Second video was shot from what looks like east side of Manhattan,
camera angle shows approach of plane and impact with building

Its simply matter of camera location and direction it was looking at.

The angle looked pretty similar, was the difference really great enough to obscure the view of the plane? I've found a few more video's that show contradicting flightpaths, this one is the best example



watch from about halfway if you want to skip the fluff.

Btw- have your co-workers ever mentioned seeing anything on tv that contradicted what they saw? it would be interesting to see if any other witnesses could share their comments also

Very interesting post. I wish I could add to it, but to me, it appears that there is a plane in one video and no plane in the other. Of course, that is obvious, but the angles looked similar enough so that you SHOULD be able to see the plane in both videos. I'm not convinced that the the powers that be made a hologram that looked like a plane flying into the building and just used explosives. I'm not sure what other explanation there is. Perhaps the first video is a fake, or at least an edited video of some sort. I'll be interested to see what others have to say. ATS is a weird place in some ways. There are great threads started and hardly anyone replies to them, then you have dumb threads and you get pages and pages of replies. Not sure why this is. Anyhow, I'm out....


JPT

It may just be my inner nerd but I love hologram theory too But I think most of the video comparisons point towards fakery, if there were holograms (or if the 911 plane images were genuine) the video's should show them moving along the same flightpath in every video of the attacks

Does anyone know where to find high quality videos of all the released second impact footage? (live and non-live) I wouldn't mind making my own comparisons but most of the video I find is already lossy from compression (i.e. youtube) and I don't want to download hours of footage to get seconds worth.