posted on May, 9 2007 @ 01:31 AM
Looking at the design of the ship, I can certainly see how this happened.
Center of balance for the ship is in the base of the first deck, nearer the bow than mid section.
Winch is above the center of balance by about one deck.
The rudder is almost perfectly in the mirror placement of the upper decks, using the center of balance as the mirror plane.
1. Ship is already top heavy.
2. Rudder design shows potential to 'shunt' the hull in a direction before the center of balance can follow.
3. Winch is above the center of balance.
... The rudder was positioned to rotate the ship to starboard, rolling the mass of the hull to port temporarily. This combined with a tension on the
'anchor chain' attached to the winch rotated the decks mass to starboard.
The mass of the center of the upper decks was thrown starboard of the center of balance, while the bouyancy of the hull was thrown port of the center
of balance. Deck comes down, hull goes up... capsize.
I don't know if the function of the ship required such mass to be in the upper decks, or if they were trying to save space... but it was a bad idea.
And the rudder shouldn't have been designed so low, it needs to shift the center of balance, not the hull itself.
Maybe if I could speak to the original engineers I could get a reason as to why these oddities were placed into the ships design... maybe they have a
good reason... but those oddities are definately the catalyst to the capsize.