posted on Jul, 19 2006 @ 04:35 PM
That comment is basically how I feel about the change in who the target audience was between Empires and and Return of the Jedi.
It's ok to roll your eyes, it's just an opinion.
A new Hope was light hearted adventure, Empire had a darker more adult feel to it, with less site gags and races designed for comedic effect...ewoks,
gungans ...races that appeared in the other films etc
When Lucus re-vamped the Star Wars series he add alot of cartoon like charactisation and slap stick scenes. They still work in film but it changed the
flavor of the film.
With Eps 1,2, 3. The actors seemed to be really stiff and the lines were delivered with drull formality.
The digital technology whilst visually impressive seemed to "deforce" these actors from any investment in the world they were portraying.
There were some terrible dialogue in these films where Lucas told people what was going on instead of showing, a good example was Kenobi "Quickly,
shoot down those Federation starships!" pointing of towards no where.
The frankenstien/Darth Vader ending!?
Where the hell did "Nooooooooooooooooooo" come from? the audience laughed at this when we saw this.
It's seemed completely out of character to hear Darth Vader scream like this. My friends have discussed this scene a lot and we generally agreed that
it would have been far more in character for Anakin to have screamed "Noooo" prior to the mask was being put in place, then as soon as the mask was
put on he became Darth Vader, cold, menacing, rasping breath Darth Vader.
I have not detailed that many examples of the child market that it was aimed at but if you can't see it in these films then don't be to worried.
I just don't don't think Lucas is above criticism and it will be nice to see more mature look at the franchise.
Most people my age if they have a favorite it's Empires...for some reason.
[edit on 19-7-2006 by Grimholt]
[edit on 19-7-2006 by Grimholt]