Guys one day you might mess with the WRONG woman!

originally posted by: ignorant_ape
a reply to: JAGStorm

how is it " obvious " that she " fights back " ?????????????????????????

Logic and common sense. The only other scenario is that she stood there and just suddenly attacked a guy for no reason at all, with an incredible amount of anger.
As I said above, if that was the case than I can only surmise that she needs urgent medical care as she would have to have a stroke or a fit or another accute mental health issue that would make her a danger to herself and the public.


OR: She was provoked/attacked and had frigging enough of people calling her fat' and she didn't want to take it lying down any longer. Add to that the missing start of the video [which is strange and could be easily seen as deliberate as it may incriminate the poor, poor guy who has friends that are also being told off] and you have got enough circumstantial reason for her behaviour.

Which scenario is more likely? Medical problems or provocation? Think.

a reply to: Hecate666

hmm - you cite " logic and common sense " - then opine an argument devoid of either

originally posted by: Hecate666

originally posted by: ignorant_ape
a reply to: JAGStorm

how is it " obvious " that she " fights back " ?????????????????????????

Logic and common sense. The only other scenario is that she stood there and just suddenly attacked a guy for no reason at all, with an incredible amount of anger.
As I said above, if that was the case than I can only surmise that she needs urgent medical care as she would have to have a stroke or a fit or another accute mental health issue that would make her a danger to herself and the public.


OR: She was provoked/attacked and had frigging enough of people calling her fat' and she didn't want to take it lying down any longer. Add to that the missing start of the video [which is strange and could be easily seen as deliberate as it may incriminate the poor, poor guy who has friends that are also being told off] and you have got enough circumstantial reason for her behaviour.

Which scenario is more likely? Medical problems or provocation? Think.

Here's a possible scenario that doesn't fit your very narrow criteria.

Lady in line is chatting on her cell phone, not paying attention to the line in front of her. As a result she is making everyone behind her wait needlessly and selfishly. The man behind her comments on that fact, and asks her to put her cell phone away and pay attention, or step aside so that everyone behind her can get what they want.

She takes exception to this and in her rage turns and attacks the man (this is a very viable and believable reaction in this day and age).

So, he neither provoked her or fat shamed her, yet he got attacked by an unstable person for no good reason.

Let's all cheer for her!!!! NOT!!!

a reply to: Krakatoa

Apart from me mentioning earlier that no violence is right, not from the woman nor the man [so you assumed I was on the woman's side], lets take your scenario and to make you feel better, just believe what you said and leave it at that.

It was a silly idea to think a young guy and his friends [which are still misbehaving on the video] could do anything wrong. I've never seen anything like that. An overweight girl on the other hand must be the aggressor, happens all the time [probably around the area you live in].


/s

originally posted by: Hecate666
a reply to: Krakatoa

Apart from me mentioning earlier that no violence is right, not from the woman nor the man [so you assumed I was on the woman's side], lets take your scenario and to make you feel better, just believe what you said and leave it at that.

It was a silly idea to think a young guy and his friends [which are still misbehaving on the video] could do anything wrong. I've never seen anything like that. An overweight girl on the other hand must be the aggressor, happens all the time [probably around the area you live in].


/s

Hmnmmm.... Did you or did you not make this statement in that post?

The only other scenario is that she stood there and just suddenly attacked a guy for no reason at all

If so, that is the issue I had with your post, and why I stated it was a narrow criteria. You claimed it was the ONLY scenario....which I showed was wrong. There are countless other valid scenarios that could explain this incident with the very short video we have seen. That is the problem, as has been stated by numerous other posters here, there is just not enough information to determine whether it was "justified" and worthy of hero status.


You just have your knickers in a twist because you got called out on your arrogant claim.

It would go a long way to being an adult to admit you were wrong to make such a narrow definitive statement with almost no real information and context.

Pfft. Married her 30 years ago.