It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
If I could impart to you what grabs me about Christ is that He is the only figure who the Universe has let play out the Messiah role in our reality.
originally posted by: KansasGirl
You say that blood was required to "pay" for us, to "pay" for humans. Why blood, and as payment for what? For sin? I can see that, I guess....I suppose if someone sins, and then kill an animal and sprinkle the blood of it on an altar, I guess it shows God that you are sorry. (???????) But why blood? What does offering blood give to God? Does it replace something that humans took?
I'm not being facetious, I really am trying to understand. No one has ever explained to me why blood is required....I've asked, and read, and haven't found an explanation...
originally posted by: dfnj2015
a reply to: Revolution9
Rather than God sending his only son I think this is a more plausible explanation of the origins of the mythology:
Caesar's Messiah: The Roman Conspiracy to Invent Jesus: Flavian Signature Edition
Most Christians do what Christians do and ignore things like this. But argument made by Atwill is extremely compelling that the Gospels were written by Flavius Josephus.
originally posted by: DeathSlayer
originally posted by: KansasGirl
You say that blood was required to "pay" for us, to "pay" for humans. Why blood, and as payment for what? For sin? I can see that, I guess....I suppose if someone sins, and then kill an animal and sprinkle the blood of it on an altar, I guess it shows God that you are sorry. (???????) But why blood? What does offering blood give to God? Does it replace something that humans took?
I'm not being facetious, I really am trying to understand. No one has ever explained to me why blood is required....I've asked, and read, and haven't found an explanation...
As the bible says.....life is in the blood....no blood ..... no life. No life = death
Payment made in blood..... by Christ for those who accept and follow Christ.
I’ve been coming to the conclusion that what this God really wants from his people is that they should be offering their own lives.
The essence of sin is that they have not been offering themselves. They have been holding something back, acting in disobedience.
So the purpose of the blood-sacrifice is to remedy that omission by presenting a symbol of the self-offering.
“We understand that we owe you our lives. Here are some lives, as a token of our debt.”
A visible offering of some kind is necessary, because this is a culture in which everything has to be acted out.
The action is expressing a recognition of their previous failure, and an implied promise to do better.
originally posted by: KansasGirl
originally posted by: DeathSlayer
originally posted by: KansasGirl
You say that blood was required to "pay" for us, to "pay" for humans. Why blood, and as payment for what? For sin? I can see that, I guess....I suppose if someone sins, and then kill an animal and sprinkle the blood of it on an altar, I guess it shows God that you are sorry. (???????) But why blood? What does offering blood give to God? Does it replace something that humans took?
I'm not being facetious, I really am trying to understand. No one has ever explained to me why blood is required....I've asked, and read, and haven't found an explanation...
As the bible says.....life is in the blood....no blood ..... no life. No life = death
Payment made in blood..... by Christ for those who accept and follow Christ.
Got it. But what about the animal sacrifices in the Old Testsment? Why was animal blood needed up be offered? In exchange for what? Your explanation says, then, that if the animals hadn't been offered on the altar, then....no life. So, everyone would then die? I appreciate your answer, but it doesn't really explain anything, not if you apply it to actual circumstances.
originally posted by: DISRAELI
a reply to: KansasGirl
I answered part of this question in my thread "Atonement in the Old Testament";
I’ve been coming to the conclusion that what this God really wants from his people is that they should be offering their own lives.
The essence of sin is that they have not been offering themselves. They have been holding something back, acting in disobedience.
So the purpose of the blood-sacrifice is to remedy that omission by presenting a symbol of the self-offering.
“We understand that we owe you our lives. Here are some lives, as a token of our debt.”
A visible offering of some kind is necessary, because this is a culture in which everything has to be acted out.
The action is expressing a recognition of their previous failure, and an implied promise to do better.
Whereas what Christ does is a genuine and complete self-offering, and that is the key.
originally posted by: DeathSlayer
originally posted by: KansasGirl
originally posted by: DeathSlayer
originally posted by: KansasGirl
You say that blood was required to "pay" for us, to "pay" for humans. Why blood, and as payment for what? For sin? I can see that, I guess....I suppose if someone sins, and then kill an animal and sprinkle the blood of it on an altar, I guess it shows God that you are sorry. (???????) But why blood? What does offering blood give to God? Does it replace something that humans took?
I'm not being facetious, I really am trying to understand. No one has ever explained to me why blood is required....I've asked, and read, and haven't found an explanation...
As the bible says.....life is in the blood....no blood ..... no life. No life = death
Payment made in blood..... by Christ for those who accept and follow Christ.
Got it. But what about the animal sacrifices in the Old Testsment? Why was animal blood needed up be offered? In exchange for what? Your explanation says, then, that if the animals hadn't been offered on the altar, then....no life. So, everyone would then die? I appreciate your answer, but it doesn't really explain anything, not if you apply it to actual circumstances.
I can see you really want to know.
Let those who are enlightened see this for what it is.
Animal sacrifices go way way back ..... before the Israelites - wasn't Cain and Able properly trained by their parents to give up a portion of their crops and livestock as an "offer" to God? Since the beginning of time an offer was made to God - an offer of thanks. The reason Cain's offer of fruits of the land was rejected and Abel's offer of animal sacrifice was accepted had nothing to do with animal sacrifice but Cain's attitude and where his heart laid on this subject and then became bitter once he saw how God accepted Abel offer and rejected Cain's. God even spoke to Cain about this and warned him to change his heart but he refused.
Offerings to God continue but something new came to mankind and it was disobedience and disrespect to God .... what we call sin today..... Now that sin comes into play, the game changes.... a price for sin must be paid and this price is high for it requires blood (life) another words a life for a life (can you understand) and the sacrificed animals blood being poured out on the altar and NOT on the ground during worship to the creator will turn his anger away from that sinner and not only forgive but FORGET that person's sin. Blessings will come to the sinner and he will prosper (meaning not die) but our creator became weary of those sacrifices, he could see it lost its original meaning (here is where one part of prophecy comes into play) animal blood no longer pays for sin .... here is where Christ comes into action by coming to earth to be the LAST and ONLY sacrifice to God, a payment so why a payment? Christ was involved with making mankind, "Lets make man in our image" He was there with his father at time of Genesis. Payment for sin was paid on the cross when he spilled out his blood and died on the cross as a man. Jesus wilfully gave up his life as a sacrifice - one reason why is also known as "The slain lamb". This sacrifice is payment ONLY for those who accept this sacrifice for themselves meaning..... you are a disciple of Christ - you sins are covered upon repentance and while walking with Christ (spiritually) will keep you on the narrow path to the Father. For some it is an easy task for others we make it too hard for ourselves - you see we expect to see everything in the physical world as truth and for the most we do - but many can not see or feel the other side - the invisible side to the human eye - the spiritual worlds. The murder of Christ covers all sin but not for everyone - those who reject Christ and REFUSE to change are NOT covered under the covenant of Christ - these people have no spiritual protection from God leaving them open to spiritual attacks.
In the beginning of the OT after the Israelites were released from Egypt and priest were assigned (Book of Leviticus) is when animal sacrifices became LAW for those who sinned including times of both both temples in Jerusalem, priests were the ones who slaughtered animals, poured its blood onto the alter, then took off certain parts of the meat for themselves and their families for they were allowed to eat parts of the sacrifice and burnt the rest of the animal in a large fire ... dedicating the animal WHICH someone had given to a priest for their sin. A perfect animal with no blemish, the best of the best, this was acceptable to our God at those times, as a SIGN of repentance and that sign was blood.
As we know the importance of blood, we forget what blood does to a living being.... we breathe properly due to proper amounts of oxygen, allowing the heart and brain to properly function... etc..... it does not take a rocket scientist to figure this one out. I cut off an arm or a leg and you will survive UNLESS you bleed out..... so body/animal parts do not cut it ..... back then when violence was on every corner..... seeing someone dead and burning at the local dump site was a common everyday way of life.... so pouring animal blood on an altar was never an offensive or disgusting sight.
Being human and walking around in my skin - I have my own issues one of them being patience ..... how I wish I could be a calm and patient man - how I LET my emotions sometimes control me and not wisdom. Failing to slow down and pray for advice and WAIT for God's answer which comes in dreams and visions. Emotions are false and fake yet we follow them - an evil effective trick that works since the Garden of Eden.
I have sinned, I am a sinner, and yet I praise the Father, Son ,and Holy Spirit knowing my sins are covered from the blood of Christ when I REPENT. Sins are NOT covered until God see you really are repentive abd see the error of your sins.
Let it be known in heaven and hell that I am a disciple and follower of Christ.