It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: Rhaegar7
Let's start with defining the Absolute.
God is the Supreme Principle of Evil and that is self-evident. It could be no other way.
This is quite an interesting thread! I would probably be considered a 'light-sider' since I just want to help everybody. I'm only 15, but my goal in life is to make everybody happy, to make everybody smile, to make everybody feel loved. So yeah, but I might be hypocritical thinking "Everything is beautiful". Though, I do not like people who rape or kill, I can see why they would think it's beautiful. I don't think it is though. Once, I thought no matter what everything was. But I am a victim of rape so it was tarnished a bit. Now, I hold the same belief but I have to put my self in their shoes & see why they would enjoy it. I'm very new to philosophy, but I enjoy it deeply. I do like your guy's beliefs too. In the way I was raised, I was made to believe a lot of what you guys said was wrong. But I see, something in it. I see a spark, & I it's so beautiful that I'm willing to burn my hand to grab it & to just feel it. Even of it's only for a second. To me, the spark is beautiful. It takes my own love & gives it to everybody else. Making my wish true. I feel like I make no sense. Oh dear, I hope you guys get what I mean? Help set it straight in a sense. See you guys around!
originally posted by: DanielKoenig
originally posted by: Rhaegar7
'Evil' and 'bad' cannot be used interchangeably.
"You don't get to decide* what's good and evil in this world."
Oh, so I don't get to choose my own way of thinking. I mean, we have the Bible to do it for us, right?
There's evil and then there's depravity and irrationality. There is depraved evil, and there is irrational evil, but there is also natural evil, necessary evil, enlightened evil. One has to acquaint himself with the darkness.
Can you explain the differences between these and give some examples? Do you think the cool sexy lucifer evil is like if you were walking in the park and saw an old lady drowning in the pond you would tip your fedora, flick your cigarette, say 'ce la vie', smirk, moonwalk away, or get our your camera phone and film it to later use for 'research purposes', is this the kind of evil, or bad, you admire, and that rules and should rule the world?
Lets say infact a God did fashion the universe, you would say this God would be evil, because it is non interfering on Earth (what if it interferes through the potential for goodness, which is largely enacted, via mankind?) you would suggest it is evil?
Would you consider it evil for the brutality and grotesqueness of biology?
God lets termites ruin peoples homes (God is therefore evil), why cant I, its not fair! Are you comparing yourself to a termite, do you want to live the life of a termite?
originally posted by: DanielKoenig
a reply to: Rhaegar7
It all has to do with an individual, awareness, being, entity, born into existence, the nature of its surroundings, the rules and rule enforcement of the beings surrounding, and the belief and truth of odds of getting caught. That last bit is maybe mostly what its about. If there is 100% chance a person (believes, and then further, rightfully believes) will not be caught and punished (by man or God) if they commit a crime, then that is the essence of evil. Someone can go wander in the woods with a bat and whack ducks and deer and birds over the head for fun, but cant do that to people. If there is no punishment, no getting caught, then everything is a free for all, and individuals can feel theoretically maximum freedom, doing what they will, whatever they want whenever they want, all that exists is the moments desiree, be it whack a person over the head with a bat or kidnap a child. Some people believe they would like to live in a world of pure anarchy, no rules, no laws, maybe? Such appears to be something like war, something like the natural biological world, of creature fighting creature. though cooperation between creatures of the same kind. Though there also seems to be some fundamental inescapability of the concept of rules, the concept of rules itself, is the concept of order, of meaning, see maybe criminals would not want anarchy, maybe criminals would not want to live in a world where everyone else is a criminal, maybe they prefer the majority of the world to be orderly and law abiding, so that they have a large source of regularity to prey on. In anarchy, anything goes, would it be each individual soley by themself, or would people who desire to follow no rules, group together and be friends, I am sure there would be some customary rules they would follow as friends, all I am trying to muse on is how 'rules' of some kind may be inescapable, thus acts of evil require logical contradictions, and though that may be the point and obvious as the essence of evil is simply the pleasures of a moments desire over all, being most important. We can see how religion and concept of soul and such come in here, because evils position is simply, I was born into a world, it seems likely this is it, I will cease to exist when I die so this is my one shot to experience anything, I am going to do absolutely anything I want when I want to and will not be caught, because nothing matters, everything is meaningless and temporary, out of infinite eternal time this moment is just an insignificant speck, so I may as well kidnap this child to enslave because it makes no difference, this child is just like a duck or deer or bird I can whack on the head with a bat, its all inconsequential, to me what I want is most important, is all that matters, hardly anything else exists.
originally posted by: DanielKoenig
What are some examples of depravity, and going down?
What are some examples of depravity, and going down? Does it all boil down to pleasure and pain? individual and collective desire? What are some examples of depravity? Are there depravities that dont harm anyone? Is this all a matter of harm? Are there depravities that are done for some reason other than pleasure, considering distraction/escape a pleasure? Ignoring the borderline minutia, would the world be better without depravities and the depraved, without the lowers and those traveling downward? Is a matter of the world being better always democratic, what is voted on being better for the most as they say? How different would the world be if the majority were bad, depraved, low, downward trend? Is there any reason the world would not want to be rid of depravity (pending on answers an definitions of that term).
The confusion of the bad and evil topics, is the minutia, and details, ala, eating bacon is evil/bad, driving your car on saturday, putting your left sock on first, etc.
Which the can potentially make individuals like you be like: that is what they define as evil/bad, its cool to be evil/bad!
Cursing is evil/bad...welp looks like I know what team im on.
But ok, this, metaphysical, discussion is about what an entity, what entities, choose is 'off limits' in terms of actions.
You believe, people believe, it should be possible for their to be no off limits, a person can and should be able to choose to believe no action is off limits, this may be the concept of nihilism, or it just depends on the consideration of 'nothing mattering' (beyond the individuals desires, which then maybe themselves are seen to not matter as long as there is or are other individuals with overpowering desires, though its not that the formers would not matter, it would just be contested, so is that it, that it is desired to exist only the free contest of desires (though yes it does all come down to the possibility, the logistics the odds and wager and leap of faith of their being no cosmic cops).
Is it right to believe there should be cosmic cops, and obviously it would entirely depend on their rule book, law book, how deep and thorough their stop and frisk cavity searches are. The cosmic cops say no bacon, God says bacon is bad/evil, God is meaningless to me, f the police, all I have is this little puff into existence all that matters is scarffing down as much pleasure as possible...oh... thats where the eternal paradise comes in with endless turkey-bacon.
I asked you once if you were God, if you created this universe or your own, what would your thoughts on evil in your creation be, and I thought your answer was a cop out, saying 'if I was God I would know much more than I do now...something something', that is not what I meant with my question, and are you presuming it is impossible for God to have ever learned anything (if God could possibly exist)? The entire point of the question was to ask you personally, entirely your own personal views. To consider the power of personal views, to imagine if each individual was solely the creator of their own universe, what they would desire.
So, what types of evil would you permit in your universe, what would you want to see, and like to see? Would you enjoy certain depravities of your creation, what ones? Would you be ok with anything goes? Would you like to see the entities that arise, create any rules or laws? Would you prefer them eternal anarchy? Would there be any point or purpose for your creation, is it possible for there to be a point or purpose? (lets imagine what you created was something like the world we are familiar with)
originally posted by: DanielKoenig
a reply to: Rhaegar7
if you knew 100% sure you could get away with it, what is/are one of the most evil and depraved things you yourself would do?
What evil/depraved thing would you do for a lot of money (millions, billions) (if you knew you could get away with it?)?
What evil/depraved things do you admire of others?
|
originally posted by: cavtrooper7
What about the ECUMINICLE TEXTS?
45 have been found since the 1800s
I mean WHO here REALLY trusts ancient ROME anyway?
OP: you sound like the edges of sociopathy...If one is a tad machiavellian maybe ...
originally posted by: LucidWarrior
a reply to: Rhaegar7
Hahaha, sounds like you might mean me
There was recently a poster in this forum that tried to explain this, but he was overly excited and started to ramble and couldn't make his point.
I think you do a very good job of staying on point and explaining the whole thing rationally, however I would like to point out some things I believe you are missing. Mainly, that Source, nothing, or as I refer to it, nothingness, IS the supreme principle of Good, while the Absolute, or Infinity, IS God, aka the supreme principle of evil. It so happens that w live in Infinity, and so we see the predominate themes of Evil. Impulses Reign, and Good is not an action, a happening, but rather a state of being- flowing naturally and true according to self imposed higher principles However, the Absolute is itself contained within the source- 1 exists inside of zero. therefore making the source even higher in power than the absolute, and thereby giving the option of freedom to those of us inside infinity, stuck within evil: we have to look within, for infinity fills and covers up Zero, and we have to dive into to spaces between things, between thoughts to attain that zen silence.
originally posted by: Willtell
The source of evil is corruption…
A dimension where corruption exists will manifest evil, pain and suffering eventually, and make it a regularized matrix where evil exists in a circle and constantly repeats itself.
Philosophically speaking life is a circle.
We get up in the morning, go to the bathroom, get breakfast, and go to work, repeatedly, so on and so on.... That is a circle.
Corruption turns the circle into an ellipse (imperfect circle) because eventually inside the circle of our life we will face evil and suffering inevitably, which is sourced in the created regularized matrix--ellipse.
Our life is an imperfect circle of suffering because the corruption is inside our faculties
This imperfect circle (our life of pain and suffering) will only resolve itself when the inner corruption of our faculties is erased.
originally posted by: namelesss
originally posted by: Rhaegar7
Let's start with defining the Absolute.
As it is not possible, let's move on.
God is the Supreme Principle of Evil and that is self-evident. It could be no other way.
What is 'self-evident' is the limitation of your understanding/vision.
God is Omni-! That means ALL inclusive; One!
All 'good', and all 'evil', exist in the vain judgmental thoughts/ego perceived and believed by the beholder. There is no 'Supreme Principle of Evil', such vanity is far from Universal! Anything carrying the vanity of the label of the 'Supreme Principle (tm) of Anything' best be, at the very least, Universal!
And, yes, God includes all ego/thought/vanity (Omni-), and also transcends.