It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: CatandtheHatchet
a reply to: WhateverYouSay
I pointed out that Grambler did not discount the message, but was pointing out some hypocritical behavior in the messenger, thus your appeal to tu quoque was a fail.
I think you are seeing what you expect to see due to CB, and are jumping the gun, it happens a lot on ATS and we are all susceptible to it.
originally posted by: WhateverYouSay
a reply to: Grambler
I am out of time but I can answer one part right now. Obama called his speech dark and pessimistic, not because it was identifying flaws but because it made it sound like there was a paradise in the past and that it's all gone wrong, when Obama has been identifying things that are problems in need of fixing but have been problems for long periods of time.
Obama characterized his speech as, ""This idea that America is somehow on the verge of collapse, this vision of violence and chaos everywhere, doesn't really jibe with the experience of most people." Which I addressed with cited facts in my previous post.
The idea that we're in collapse is fear mongering, and it's Trumps bread and butter.
For what it's worth, you say I agree with many of Trumps identification of problems, I think if you reread you'll notice that Trumps main selling points are the ones I disagree with - such as illegal immigration, increasingly heavy handed police tactics, tax breaks for the richest, and you left out some of the most important like global warming.
originally posted by: xuenchen
People need to realize Obama is on his last leg now.
He will do as much damage as possible to make it difficult for the next Administration regardless who it is.
He won't consider the damage to the majority of Citizens either. The more the better in his mind.
Everyone needs to be very careful of Obama's sneaky tricks.
Sorry but if you claim someone is "talking down to you" you're not going to listen to the message. It's tu quoque.
originally posted by: WhateverYouSay
a reply to: CatandtheHatchet
I will reply to this later because this is the only thing I find interesting about the thread.
Ok, here it is. With tu quoque you can either make the conclusions wrong or irrelevant, it is the latter in this point. By the first post the arguments have already been dismissed, and is putting the conclusion before the arguments which occurred in his lengthy post. The title of the thread is not "Obama is a hypocrite", it is "Obama talks down the US", which both sets the theme and provides evidence for why it should be dismissed.
Whether or not this was intentionally committed by Grambler I don't know, but it probably was not intentional. I would argue this form of tu quoque *is* actually intentional by those in power.