It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: ketsuko
a reply to: Klassified
Christians are supposed to live their faith. For some people, that's all it take to "project" our beliefs on them. Those are typically the same people who can't seem to understand that faith does not end in the pews on Sunday.
Are you going to tell me that you have never sinned in your life? If so, I'd call you a liar. No sin is any worse than another. So why don't you take a seat and reflect on what that means. We are all sinners. Christians aren't immune to this--so stop lying to yourself. Don't judge others.
Did you know that during the civil war,
it was the Republicans that fought to
free and slaves and the Democrats
who wanted to keep slavery legal ?
originally posted by: ketsuko
a reply to: Klassified
Some things are sin no matter what you choose to call them.
What do you call murder? It's a sin. What do you call lying? Is it right? If not, it's a sin. Just because you use a different word to make yourself feel better about it doesn't change the fact that you like still view some things as wrong, morally and ethically. To get offended because you use a different word, not sin, doesn't change the fact that we still look at those acts in much the same way.
originally posted by: Antidisestablishment
I think you are mistaken in thinking that the concept of sin is purely a Christian invention which doesn't exist in other religions.
originally posted by: Klassified
a reply to: grandmakdw
So you think ALL Christians are misogynistic, homophobic, gay haters? You just defined your self as judgmental, bigoted, prejudiced, and Christophobic with those statements. Let's not forget highly intolerant.
I don't think all Christians necessarily fall under that umbrella, but their bible certainly does.
Prove it with the words of Jesus, not the Old Testament, but with the words of Jesus.
You have to know that Christians believe that the words of Jesus supersede anything written in the old Testament.
Many Christians say they are not Pauline Christians, that is follow the words of Paul.
All Christians follow the words of Christ, so if you want to respond to ALL Christians and give your message to ALL Christians, and prove to ALL Christians how misogynistic, homophobic and gay hating Jesus teaches them to be, then Find the words of Christ himself saying misogynistic, homophobic, gay hating things. If you don't know how to find them, there are bible with red letters (the red letters are the words of Christ). Or check online for the actual words that Christ said. These words only exist in Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, and a few in the early part of Acts.
That is the ONLY way you can prove your contention. As a Christian who has spent many years in the military I have been close to all "brands" of Christians and can point you to the only biblical words that ALL Christians agree upon.
originally posted by: Klassified
a reply to: grandmakdw
Prove it with the words of Jesus, not the Old Testament, but with the words of Jesus.
I love it when Christians move the goal posts when it suits them. Shame on you, Grandma. I will then ask a question of you. Why are billions of Christians vehemently opposed to gay marriage, and say that homosexuality is a sin, if Jesus was just fine with it? Where does that homophobia come from, I wonder?
You have to know that Christians believe that the words of Jesus supersede anything written in the old Testament.
Matt 5 - 17“Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. 18For truly I tell you, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished...
This says to me, that in fulfilling the law, by living a sinless life, Jesus became the embodiment of the law. Your sins are forgiven because of his sacrifice. But what constitutes sin hasn't changed. So what god pronounced as an abomination in the OT, is still an abomination, but you can be forgiven for it without sacrificing defenseless animals and people. Secondly, Jesus corrected certain certain tenants while he was here in the flesh. For instance, an eye for an eye. Are you telling me his silence on homosexuality nullifies god's view of it, and we can also strike everything Paul said about it? Why not tear out the epistles, and the old testament, and live strictly by what Jesus said then?
Many Christians say they are not Pauline Christians, that is follow the words of Paul.
Many in comparison to what? The overwhelming majority of Christendom accept the epistles as divinely inspired. When did individual Christians become arbiters of what is scripture, and what is not? No wonder there are thousands of sects, and even Christians can't come together as one group.
All Christians follow the words of Christ, so if you want to respond to ALL Christians and give your message to ALL Christians, and prove to ALL Christians how misogynistic, homophobic and gay hating Jesus teaches them to be, then Find the words of Christ himself saying misogynistic, homophobic, gay hating things. If you don't know how to find them, there are bible with red letters (the red letters are the words of Christ). Or check online for the actual words that Christ said. These words only exist in Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, and a few in the early part of Acts.
Nice deflection Grandma. See my above comment. Again. If Jesus was silent on any topic, he was cool with it. So Jesus had no problem with LGBT, or gay marriage. He also had no issue with slavery, rape, and a host of other issues either, then. Right?
That is the ONLY way you can prove your contention. As a Christian who has spent many years in the military I have been close to all "brands" of Christians and can point you to the only biblical words that ALL Christians agree upon.
Grandma, you know full well my background. Trying to use this argument with me is fruitless and disingenuous. When Christians throw away everything but the gospels, and stop moving the goalposts when it suits them, because they think the person they're talking to is ignorant, then we might get somewhere.
originally posted by: Klassified
originally posted by: DBCowboy
originally posted by: Antidisestablishment
Hey you Bible Bashers!
Do you have an answer to me question.
I have been reading the New Testament, and I really can't find any evidence that the beloved Jesus you so admire would have ever voted for Bush or Donald Trump. In fact, I don't even belive he was homophobic.
In fact, I don't think he was misogynistic or a gay hater.
Can you prove me wrong by posting scriptures that support capitalism and slavery which actually came from Jesus's mouth?
I think the early disciples showed more left wing leanings tbh.
It seems to be a theme here to attack Christians, conservative Christians.
Who cares who Jesus would have voted for?
There has been a theme among Christians to "attack" anyone who is not, for 2000 years.
Sincere question: What is a conservative Christian, and is it biblical?
originally posted by: Antidisestablishment
Hey you Bible Bashers!
Do you have an answer to me question.
I have been reading the New Testament, and I really can't find any evidence that the beloved Jesus you so admire would have ever voted for Bush or Donald Trump. In fact, I don't even belive he was homophobic.
In fact, I don't think he was misogynistic or a gay hater.
Can you prove me wrong by posting scriptures that support capitalism and slavery which actually came from Jesus's mouth?
I think the early disciples showed more left wing leanings tbh.
I am not moving any goalposts. I am pointing out the ONLY places where you can find the ONLY things that ALL Christians can agree on. If Jesus never said it then not all Christians will agree.
So in order to prove your point you must find the things you claim Christians are using the words of Christ himself.
P.S. (addition) Sorry, I really don't know your background, please share it with us. You also know from my writings that I am not homophobic and don't care at all who marries who, that is their business, not mine, and I'd say 95% of my many many Christian friends are like me, don't care what people choose to do as long as they don't harm others or try to force us to believe as they do, in nothing. And I am (gasp) an evil Christian!
Almost forgot: Everything was accomplished when he died and I believe (even if you don't) he rose again. He said on the cross, "It is finished", or some scholars say he actually said "It is accomplished." You also know that Jesus said people could eat anything, against the Old Testament; he also "worked" on the Sabbath, which made the religious people of his day angry because it was against the Old Testament law, he at with Prostitutes and the unclean which was against the Old Testament. He touched lepers which was against the Old Testament rules.
originally posted by: Klassified
a reply to: grandmakdw
I am not moving any goalposts. I am pointing out the ONLY places where you can find the ONLY things that ALL Christians can agree on. If Jesus never said it then not all Christians will agree.
First. I would remind you, I said the bible, not Jesus words by themselves. A statement I stand by. That said...
Evidently, you are among the very small percentage of Christians that believe the way you do. Every Christian I know(and I know many) say homosexuality is a sin, and gay marriage is wrong according to the bible. They also believe women are to be submitted to men, the same way the church is in submission to Christ. Though they don't live what they're telling me. Yet you say neither is true, if I'm understanding you correctly. You're telling me that everything in the epistles, and the OT, is incorrect if Jesus didn't address it. I hope you don't mind. I'm bookmarking this discussion for the next Christian on ATS that tells me homosexuality is a sin, as well as gay marriage. But I have to ask you, what the hell is wrong with the rest of Christianity if your small group believes the way you do, and hundreds of millions of Christians across the world don't? Why are they all so up in arms over these things then?
As to all Christians agreeing on Jesus words. I think you know that isn't true. I've seen Christians berate each other right here on ATS over what Jesus meant by what he said, or didn't say. However, I will agree that most will at least tell you that Jesus words reign supreme, even if they can't agree on what he did or didn't say.
So in order to prove your point you must find the things you claim Christians are using the words of Christ himself.
No. Actually I don't have to. I said the bible, and I meant the bible as a whole. Not Jesus words alone. You don't get to dictate what can, and cannot be included as "proof". Nor can you speak for over 2 billion Christians who believe the bible as a whole, rather than ripping out everything but Jesus words to keep from having to admit the bible is misogynistic and homophobic. Most of them believe their whole bible is inspired by god, and use the old, as well as the new in their faith. Granted they, like you, cherry pick what they like, and throw the rest out, but that does not change the fact, it is there in black, red, and white.
P.S. (addition) Sorry, I really don't know your background, please share it with us. You also know from my writings that I am not homophobic and don't care at all who marries who, that is their business, not mine, and I'd say 95% of my many many Christian friends are like me, don't care what people choose to do as long as they don't harm others or try to force us to believe as they do, in nothing. And I am (gasp) an evil Christian!
One Man's Journey
There's much more in my posts across ATS, but this is it in a nutshell.
And this quote of your post is more like it. This is how I wish all Christians thought. Faith is a personal thing. And unlike the anti-theists, I have no desire to see peoples religious freedom extinguished. As long as it remains personal, I don't see the issue with people believing in whatever deity they choose.
Almost forgot: Everything was accomplished when he died and I believe (even if you don't) he rose again. He said on the cross, "It is finished", or some scholars say he actually said "It is accomplished." You also know that Jesus said people could eat anything, against the Old Testament; he also "worked" on the Sabbath, which made the religious people of his day angry because it was against the Old Testament law, he at with Prostitutes and the unclean which was against the Old Testament. He touched lepers which was against the Old Testament rules.
What you have stated here is why I believe if Jesus existed, there are a lot of words attributed to him that he didn't say. There are things in the gospels that just don't sound like something he would have preached or taught. He did the things you mention on the one hand, and yet condemned people to hell on the other. Something is wrong with this picture.
Whatever the case, interesting exchange grandma. I learned some things about you today I didn't know, and they were good to hear. We are both equally obstinate. And that's not always a bad thing.
That is my goal to fight the intolerance, bigotry, prejudice, and yes hatred that is spewed in the name of tolerance by many on ATS. Expect me to keep fighting.