It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: CretumOrbis
a reply to: Asynchrony
Censorship is the deliberate suppression of one person's self-expression by another for the perceived benefit of a third-party. In other words, it's an attempt at forcing people to conform to an ideology. It's also utterly pointless, pragmatically speaking, since words have no inherent meaning. You can ban a word but it's meaning can simply be attached to a new word or substituted by a word from a foreign language. That concept is the reason we have a multitude of languages on this planet and was the basis for Orwell's 'newspeak'.
For every so-called curse word there is at least one synonym that is considered acceptable by the very same culture. In most cases though, these words have no more meaning than the likes of 'eek', 'wow', or 'yikes'. If there's nothing wrong with the meaning of the word, why then is a particular sequence of symbols so deplorable?
Wait, let me rephrase that...
Frelling dren, what the yotz are those fahrbot hazmots thinking?!
originally posted by: okamitengu
I personally don't believe in censorship. responsible adults should be able to make up their own minds about what they watch
however, there needs to be clear warnings for content.
some prude in an office should not get to decide for everyone what is right and wrong.
originally posted by: CretumOrbis
a reply to: Asynchrony
Thanks for emphasizing my point. What you just described is an ideology. If it's purely about being insulted, again, the words themselves have no relevance - only the manner in which they're used. You may find cursing to be unattractive or repulsive but some may feel the exact opposite, myself included. I find the very notion of nobility, or class structure in general, to be revolting. Your opinion of what is 'high-class' or 'low-brow' is just that, an opinion, and is no more relevant than the opinion of any other human on this planet. If you don't like it, don't look. I don't have the right to force you to look, nor should anyone have the right to force someone to refrain from it either.
Censorship is to fascism as algebra is to mathematics. That, in a nutshell, is the point Orwell was trying to make with his concept of newspeak. Censorship in any form for any reason should be just as revolting and unacceptable as any other form of fascism.